The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 4, March, 1836Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 4, March, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Let a system of education make provision for nothing but what is
elevated and useful, and still space enough will be left for all the
frivolity and sporting which any can deem to be absolutely essential.
These things will take care of themselves, and will inevitably come
in, on any plan that may be adopted, to secure all the advantages
which they are capable of affording.
Another objection which has been preferred to manual labor schools
is, _that they contribute but little or nothing to the support of the
student_.
The truth on this subject, as could be satisfactorily shown is, that,
as might naturally be expected, manual labor schools, being a novel
experiment in this country, have had to struggle, as do all similar
enterprises of benevolence at the outset, with formidable obstacles;
and in some instances, through injudiciousness in their location, or
mismanagement in their arrangements, have either been abandoned, or
have failed to fulfil the expectations of their projectors.
Mercantile and other adventurers often fail in their plans. At the
same time it is undeniable, that some institutions of this sort have
succeeded beyond all previous calculations, and the students that
composed them have not only enjoyed better health than others, and
made more rapid advances in knowledge, but a portion of them have, by
the avails of their labors, defrayed _the whole_ of their expenses; a
few have done _more_; and a majority have diminished them about
_one-half_. Manual labor establishments, therefore, will do
_something_ (we ought not to expect them to do _every thing_,)
towards _cheapening_ education, even in the infancy of their
existence; and the thought can hardly fail to be cheering to American
republicans and patriots, that in the full tide of successful
operation which we believe will attend their maturer age, "full many
a flower" which but for them would be "born to bloom and blush
unseen," will shed its "sweetness on" Columbia's "air."
But admit for a moment that manual labor schools are an utter failure
as regards _the pecuniary advantages which they afford_. Admit, if
you please, that the manual labor feature is an expensive part of
education, and that to comply with it an education will cost more
than on any other plan. The argument for their utility remains alike
unanswered and unshaken. Is not the education thus obtained a more
perfect one? Is it not immensely more valuable? Are health, morals,
useful habits, vigorous intellects, and life, worth nothing? Is money
expended for the improvement and preservation of these thrown away?
If manual labor schools increased the expenses of education
_fourfold_, they would still deserve the warm patronage of the
public, and all who have the ability should send their sons to them
to be educated, in preference to any other institutions, even should
they have as many of them as the Patriarch, or be endowed with the
riches of Crœsus.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account