The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
great man—interesting as illustrations of the strong common sense
which peculiarly distinguished him. “Lionel Granby” is one of the best
chapters which has appeared under that title. A novel however,
published at intervals in the pages of a monthly miscellany,
necessarily loses by that circumstance much of its interest. The
author of “Odds and Ends” has attempted with much humor and effect, a
new moral classification of that strange compound animal called Man.
His satire is for the most part just, and his style racy and
agreeable. “Random Thoughts,” saving and excepting one or two smutty
allusions, are excellent. They have an air of freshness and
originality, which is quite delightful, considering how little can be
said which is new upon any subject. The Lecture on “German
Literature,” by Mr. Calvert of Baltimore, now for the first time
published, is highly creditable to its author. It evinces much
classical taste, combined with a spirit of philosophical criticism.
Mr. Calvert is sometimes, however, careless in his style, or rather in
the formation of his sentences, which a good writer should study to
avoid; and the great literary sin of this country, _a propensity to
bombast_—is discernible in some parts of his lecture. Take for example
the following passage, “John Wolfgang Goethe, was born at Frankfort on
the Maine, in 1749, ten years before Schiller. ‘Selectest influences,’
leagued with nature, to produce this wonderful man. To give its
complete development to a mighty inward power, outward circumstances
were most happily propitious. _Upon faculties of the quickest
sensibility, and yet of infinitely elastic power—wide convulsions and
world-disturbing incidents bore with tempestuous force, dilating the
congenial energies of the young genius who suddenly threw out his
fiery voice to swell the tumult round him, and announce the master
spirit of the age._” This would certainly be a very unfair specimen of
the general character of the lecture, and it is the more surprising,
that such a sentence should have escaped the vigilance of the author.
The slightest departure from the simplest mode of expression, if it
does not degenerate into bombast, is almost certain to be attended by
a certain degree of obscurity. The author of the “Hall of Incholese,”
is himself not free from this blemish. The following passage is
entirely unintelligible: “The Spanish minister was married; but a star
on the fashionable horizon higher than the vesta of his own choice,
prompted the proffer of his help, in the establishment of a medium
point of lustre.” The meaning might be guessed at by very laborious
study—but popular literature should never levy so severe a tax upon
its subjects. The paper on “American Social Elevation,” contains many
just thoughts and patriotic reflections, expressed in an unusually
agreeable style—and the 4th No. of “Readings with my Pencil,” is quite
passable.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account