The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 9, August, 1836Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 9, August, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Now, whilst it is fully conceded that the figure of _personification_
is perfectly legitimate, especially in poetry; yet there are certain
degrees of it which should never be attempted, unless connected with
subjects of great dignity, or which inspire powerful emotion—and it
must not be forgotten that the excellence of poetry does not consist
so much in the form or arrangement of its words as in the value and
beauty of the thoughts and sentiments which it expresses. A gentle
zephyr stealing into a lady's bower and lulling her into repose, or
whispering in her ear the sighs of an absent lover, is natural and
agreeable enough; but a river, or even rivulet, turning from its
course and performing the same office, is a conception which would be
very ridiculous in any other than a _popular_ poet. It would be
tedious to point out other examples of similar extravagance in Moore,
and one only shall suffice—a song which has occasioned abundant
fluttering in female hearts, and which for impious hyperbole was never
excelled:
Why does azure deck the sky,
But to be like thine eyes of blue?
Why is red the rose's dye?
Because it is thy blush's hue, &c. &c.
In which said song the poet very calmly shows that all that is bright,
and fair, and sweet in creation, was made purposely to resemble some
young lady of his acquaintance. And yet all these trifles and
absurdities, to say nothing of the frequent obscene allusions of the
same author, have acquired an extensive popularity under the influence
of a popular _name_.
It would be no difficult task to extend these remarks so as to embrace
a long list of distinguished writers, both in prose and verse, who
have perpetrated various offences against sound morals as well as good
sense, but with whom the lustre of reputation, like the mantle of
charity, has not only shielded them from censure, but imparted a kind
of dignity and splendor to their failings. Enough perhaps has been
said to illustrate the influence of names in the empire of literature.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account