The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 9, August, 1836Various
History
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 9, August, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
“_How many years of life are spent in learning Latin? How much labor,
pain and imprisonment, are endured by the boy? How much anxious
drudgery by the master? How much disgust of literature is engendered?_
How many habits are formed of reluctance to regular employment? In
short, how much misery has been produced, is being produced, and will
continue to be produced, in teaching the Latin language? This appears
to us to be a very important question, and will, we think, appear so
to our readers, after a little consideration.
“We sometimes figure to ourselves an inhabitant of another world
coming among us, and examining with an unprejudiced eye the _value_ of
our pursuits. If this idle speculation could be realized, who, we
should be glad to know, would be Quixotic enough to undertake a
defence of the usual course of instruction in Latin? Nobody,
certainly. For, in the first place, not two boys out of three who
follow it, ever become able _to read even the easier classic authors
with fluency_. Of these, perhaps one half, from the painful
associations which they have attached to Latin books, never open one
after they leave school. If we add to the account, as Rousseau would,
the numbers who die during the schoolboy age, we shall find the list
of those who use the knowledge, gained with so much pain to master and
scholar, dwindle into a very small one.”—_Essay on Public Education,
p. 12. London, 1822._
“I object to the practice of sending, almost indiscriminately, every
male child, whose parents are above the laboring class of the people,
to undergo the painful {559} drudgery of committing to memory the
rules of a Latin Grammar, and _to sacrifice four of the years of his
existence to a pursuit which is ultimately to be of no service to
him_.”—_Russel's View of the Scotch System of Education, p. 85._
“Does it savor of our characteristic sagacity to send almost every boy
of a certain age, to a grammar school, to learn the elements of Latin,
and afterwards to enter him to business, with no other qualifications
for it than those which he may have derived from a partial and
ill-directed attention to writing and accounts?”—_Idem, p. 79._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account