The Speeches & Table-Talk of the Prophet Mohammad — John Shaqi
The Speeches & Table-Talk of the Prophet MohammadMuhammad, Prophet
Islamic
The Speeches & Table-Talk of the Prophet Mohammad
Muhammad, Prophet
Muhammad, Prophet, -632 -- Teachings; Religious life -- Islam
The actual legal residue in the Medina chapters is singularly small.
Chapters ii., iv., and v., contain nearly all the law of the Korān; but
it must be allowed they are very long chapters, and form nearly a tenth
part of it. Their practical import,--the definite ruling of Mohammad
on dogmatic, ritual, civil, and criminal matters,--is collected in pp.
133-144, and need not be repeated here. The conclusion, however, is
worth pointing clearly. The Korān does not contain, even in outline,
the elaborate ritual and complicated law which now passes under the
name of Islām. It contains merely those decisions which happened to be
called for at Medina. Mohammad himself knew that it did not provide for
every emergency, and recommended a principle of analogical deduction to
guide his followers when they were in doubt. This analogical deduction
has been the ruin of Islām. Commentators and jurists have set their
nimble wits to work to extract from the Korān legal decisions which an
ordinary mind could never discover there; and the whole structure of
modern Mohammadanism has been built upon this foundation of sand. The
Korān is not responsible for it.
There is, however, another source of information about Mohammad’s
teaching and practice which is largely responsible for the present
form of the once simple creed of Mekka. Besides the public speeches
which were held to be directly inspired by God, and indeed copied from
a book supposed to exist in the handwriting of God,--the chapters
of the Korān,--there were many sayings of Mohammad which were said
in a private unofficial way in his circle of intimate friends, and
which were almost as carefully treasured up as the others. These are
the Traditions, or as I may call them, the Table-Talk of Mohammad,
for they correspond more nearly to what we mean by table-talk than
any other form of composition. The Table-Talk of Mohammad deals with
the most minute and delicate circumstances of life, and is much more
serviceable to the lawyer than the Korān itself. The sayings are
very numerous and very detailed; but how far they are genuine it is
not easy to determine. The Korān is known beyond any doubt to be at
this moment, in all practical respects, identical with the prophet’s
words as collected immediately after his death. How it was edited and
collected may be read elsewhere. The only point to be here insisted
on is that its genuineness is above suspicion. Unfortunately, as much
cannot be said for the Traditions. They were collected at a late
period, subjected to a totally useless and preposterous criticism, and
thus reduced from 600,000 to 7275, without becoming in the least more
trustworthy in the process. It is almost impossible now to sift them
with any certainty. All we can go upon is internal evidence, and a few
obvious contradictions in date--as when people relate things which
they apparently heard before they were born. Beyond this, criticism
is helpless, and all we can do is what I have done here--to collect
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account