The Speeches & Table-Talk of the Prophet MohammadMuhammad, Prophet
Islamic
The Speeches & Table-Talk of the Prophet Mohammad
Muhammad, Prophet
Muhammad, Prophet, -632 -- Teachings; Religious life -- Islam
They are doubtless couched in more barbaric language
than we are accustomed to, and where we insinuate, Mohammad curses
outright. But in the face of a treacherous and malignant opposition,
the Arabian prophet comported himself with singular self-restraint. He
only threatened hell-fire, and people of all denominations are still
threatened with that every Sunday, to say nothing of Lent. Leaving out
the Jewish stories, needless repetitions, and temporary exhortations
or personal vindications, the speeches of Mohammad may be set forth
in very moderate compass. One speech--_sura_, or chapter, as it is
generally called--follows another so much to the same effect, that a
limited number will be found to contain all the ideas which a minute
study of the whole Korān could collect. I believe there is nothing
important, either in doctrine or style, which is not contained in the
twenty-eight speeches which fill the first hundred and thirty pages of
this small volume. If I were a Mohammadan, I think I could accept the
present collection as a sufficient representation of what the Korān
teaches.
The obscurity of the Korān is largely due to its ordinary arrangement.
This consists merely in putting the longest chapters first and the
shortest last. The Mohammadans appear to be contented with this curious
order, which after all is not more remarkable than that of some other
sacred books. German criticism, however, has discovered the method of
arranging the Korān in approximately chronological sequence. To explain
how this is established would carry me too far, but the results are
certain. We can state positively that the chapters of the Korān--or,
as I prefer to call them, the speeches of Mohammad--fall into certain
definite chronological groups, and if we cannot arrange each individual
speech in its precise place, we can at least tell to which group,
extending over but few years, it belongs. The effect of this critical
arrangement is to throw a perfectly clear light on the development
of Mohammad’s teaching, and the changes in his style and method.
When the Korān is thus arranged--as it is in Mr. Rodwell’s charming
version, which deserves to be better read than it is--the impression
of anarchy disappears, and we see only the growth of a remarkable
mind, the alternations of weakness and strength in a gifted soul, the
inevitable inconsistencies of a great man. I do not believe any one who
reads the speeches of Mohammad as I have arranged them in Professor
Nöldeke’s chronological order will say that they have no definite aim
or coherence. They may be monotonous, and often they are rambling, but
their intention and sequence of thought are to me clear as noonday.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account