The Stock Exchange from WithinVan Antwerp, William C. (William Clarkson)
History
The Stock Exchange from Within
Van Antwerp, William C. (William Clarkson)
New York Stock Exchange; Stock exchanges
Booms are not made on the Stock Exchange; they are made in the
country’s fields and forests and workshops. Panics are not created
there; they have their origin in mistakes and excesses throughout the
world, and in psychologic conditions which stock markets cannot hope
to control. The pendulum may swing far, but it comes back. Sooner or
later the movement of prices tells the exact story of future business,
and of credit, and of all the economic agencies that enter into them.
This was not well understood in 1907, and, as I said at the beginning,
I doubt if it will ever be understood in the sense that it will avoid
a recurrence of panics. All that we may hope for is that periods of
depression, which are inevitable, may not be attended in future by
such a loss of the reasoning faculties as that which brought about the
affair of 1907.
Now let us consider another cause of the panic--the currency system,
always bearing in mind the fact that the first and greatest cause of
the panic was the over-expansion outside of New York that has just
been described. The causes which we are now to consider were of minor
importance when measured by this overshadowing matter; nevertheless
they played their part and must be considered accordingly.
Not all panics, to be sure, can be prevented by a perfect currency
system, yet this one could have been measurably prevented, and “Wall
Street” and the Stock Exchange had labored for years so to prevent it.
At the gatherings of the Chamber of Commerce, at the bank meetings, at
all the meetings of merchants and manufacturers for years preceding
1907, the mischievous effects of our currency system were proclaimed
and the ultimate outcome predicted. Congress was petitioned again and
again to remedy those intolerable conditions, and to permit national
banks to expand their circulation under proper safeguards, but without
avail.
When the storm burst, a most impressive object lesson in practical
finance resulted. What was at worst but a normal stringency of the
circulating medium developed, when added to abnormal demands from the
country at large, into conditions that created great alarm. There was
no way by which the banks of the country could use the resources which
they actually possessed to meet the urgent requirements of the hour.
A great nation of enterprising people found itself--and still finds
itself--compelled to do a banking business differing in degree, but not
in kind, from the old-woman-and-her-stocking system of finance. The
way our bankers got down on their knees to London and Paris in that
emergency, frankly admitting their inability, under our old flint-lock
laws, to handle a situation which foreign bankers meet without
difficulty, is a subject at once painful and humiliating. Literally our
bankers begged for help and got it. Some day we shall have to beg again.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account