This line of argument, however, only removes the difficulty one step
further. Sensation is said always to reproduce faithfully the picture
which affects the organs of sense, but the pictures do not always
reproduce the object with equal faithfulness. How then can a faithful
picture be known from one which is not faithful? To this question the
Epicurean system can furnish no real answer. To say that the wise man
knows how to distinguish a faithful from an unfaithful picture [1145]
is to despair of an absolute standard at all, and to make the decision
of truth or error depend upon the individual’s judgment. Such a
statement reduces all our impressions of the properties of things to a
relative level. If sensation does not show us things themselves, but
only those impressions of them which happen to affect us, it does not
supply us with a knowledge of things as they are, but as they happen to
be related to us. It was, therefore, a legitimate inference from this
theory of knowledge for Epicurus to deny that colour belongs to bodies
in themselves, since some only see colour in the dark, whilst others do
not. [1146] Like his predecessor, Democritus, he must have been brought
to this view by his theory of atoms. Few of the properties belong to
atoms which we perceive in things, and hence all other properties must
be explained as not belonging to the essence, but only to the
appearance of things. [1147] The taste for speculation was, however,
too weak, and the need of a direct truth of the senses too strong in
Epicurus for him to be able to turn his thoughts in this direction for
long. Whilst allowing to certain properties of things only a relative
value, he had no wish to doubt the reality of objects, nor to disparage
the object-pictures which furnish us with sensations. [1148]
CHAPTER XVII.
THE EPICUREAN VIEWS ON NATURE.
[A. General views on nature.]
[(1) Object, value, and method of the study of nature.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account