The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
Little would ever be heard of objections to Vaccination, if all
who undertake the responsibility of its performance, and all who
feel disposed to resist its adoption, _would but thoroughly study
that masterpiece of medical induction_, and imitate the patience
and caution and modesty with which Jenner laid the foundations of
every statement he advanced.
In the first _Inquiry into the Causes and Effects of the Variolæ
Vaccinæ_, Jenner set on a scientific basis the popular belief to
which I have referred; and the close of the 18th Century, which
had much to darken it, will be remembered till the end of human
history for the greatest physical good ever yet given by science
to the world.--_Papers relating to the History and Practice of
Vaccination._ Pp. xi. and xii. London, 1857.
These are the words of Mr. John Simon, and in them we have the
Jennerian legend with the morsel of fact to the mass of fable
which characterises legendary matter, ancient and modern. The
recommendation to “study thoroughly that master-piece of medical
induction,” Jenner’s _Inquiry_, is a mere flourish of panegyric;
for, as Mr. Simon was well aware, the book had been out of print
for half a century, and was practically inaccessible; whilst
its reproduction has usually been considered undesirable in the
interests of Vaccination, inasmuch as it reveals more than is
expedient for common knowledge. An idol that is good to swear by is
always fortified by a convenient obscurity.
The _Inquiry_ is a quarto of less than seventy pages in large
type, set in broad margins in the grand style of the period,
and illustrated with four coloured plates. There are eight pages
of Introductory Matter, followed by thirty-four pages of Cases,
concluding with twenty-six pages of General Observations.
It is to the Cases as the ground of the argument, that I would
first direct attention. They are twenty-three, and may be thus
assorted--
13 of Cowpox communicated by accident.
4 of Horsegrease communicated by accident and inoculated by design.
6 of Cowpox inoculated by design or transferred from arm-to-arm.
It may be tedious, but I should like to go with the reader over
these Cases, for they are highly instructive. Let us take the first
twelve of Cowpox communicated by accident.
I.--JOSEPH MERRET, Gardener.
In 1770 attended to Horses, milked Cows, and caught Cowpox.
Afterwards his family had Smallpox, but he escaped. In 1795 Jenner
repeatedly inoculated him with Smallpox without effect.
II.--SARAH PORTLOCK, Farm Servant.
In 1771 had Cowpox. In 1792 nursed her child in Smallpox
“conceiving herself secure,” and was at the same time inoculated
with Smallpox in both arms without effect.
III.--JOHN PHILLIPS, Tradesman.
Had Cowpox when nine years old. Was inoculated with Smallpox by
Jenner at the age of 62 without effect.
IV.--MARY BARGE, Farm Servant.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account