The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
These are Jenner’s Cases. In them we have his “Masterpiece of
Medical Induction”--the fruit of thirty years of incessant thought,
of watching, and of experiment! Let us carefully observe the
dates. Until 1796, when he operated on Phipps, he never made an
experiment in Horsegrease Cowpox Inoculation; and not until the
middle of March, 1798, a few weeks before going to press with the
_Inquiry_, did he repeat the experiment; and though his later
cases were complicated with erysipelas, he did not stay to dispose
of the difficulty and alarm thereby excited. He got together his
scratch lot of Cases, as if under some over-mastering compulsion,
and consigned the concern, crude and incomplete, to the public.
By-and-by the hasty performance came to be spoken of as the result
of thirty years of incessant thought, of patient research, and of
unwearied labour. It is unnecessary to argue the matter. Whilst
there is nothing too great for the credulity of those who are in
the disposition of belief, yet facts are facts, and there is the
stone-wall of the _Inquiry_ with its authentic details whereon to
crack the skulls of romancers. In Jenner’s story as recited to the
vulgar, we have the advantage of witnessing the development of
myth in the light of our own age under our own eyes.
Taking Jenner’s _Inquiry_ at the utmost, What was it? A suggestion
to substitute Horsegrease Cowpox for Smallpox in inoculation.
That was all. Beyond this there was no point of novelty. Some
have credited Jenner with originating the transfer of virus from
arm to arm; but in this respect he followed the example of many
variolators. There was a mild form of Smallpox occasionally
prevalent in London called “pearly pox,” and Dr. Adams and others
kept it going from patient to patient; and the virus from the body
of a healthy variolated child was in constant request by timid
folk, who fancied the virulence of the original infection might
thereby be abated in transmission.
So much for Jenner’s data. Now for a word or two as to the
speculation that invested his prescription.
He considered that some of the diseases which afflict men are
derived from their domestication of animals, and that thus several
diseases might have a common origin. “For example,” he asked, “Is
it difficult to imagine that measles, scarlet fever, and ulcerous
sore throat with a spotted skin, have all sprung from the same
source?”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account