The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
This cowpox is commended as “pure lymph from the calf,” a sweet
periphrase with a savour of Daphne and Chloe, of Flora and the
country green--a periphrase used in craft or ignorance, “pure
lymph” being as incapable of producing vaccinia as pure milk or
pure saliva. The prescription takes us back to Jenner’s time
and Jenner’s procedure. As has been said, the Gloucestershire
dairymaids believed that after cowpox they were safe from smallpox,
and that Jenner was much impressed with their belief until he
discovered that it was untrue. Had he found it true, he might
have advertised the prophylactic thirty years in advance of the
publication of his _Inquiry_; but if anything was certain, this
was certain, that cowpox did not avert smallpox. Satisfied that
cowpox _per se_ was of no avail against smallpox, he defined a
variety of cowpox generated by the application of horsegrease, to
which he was pleased to ascribe sovereign efficacy. Why, I ask,
did he discriminate and prescribe that variety of cowpox if cowpox
_per se_ was effective? The question answers itself. I will not
say the cowpoxers treat Jenner’s evidence with disrespect; for
such is their ignorance, that I question if they are aware of
its existence; moreover, that which is undesirable to know, is
instinctively avoided and kept out of sight. They recommend their
“lymph” as wonderfully mild, being attended with no erysipelas, the
pest of arm-to-arm vaccination--a description that tallies exactly
with Jenner’s of impotent cowpox. “The pustules,” says Jenner, “are
of a much milder nature” than those of horsegrease cowpox. “_No
erysipelas attends them_, and they are incapable of producing any
specific effect on the human constitution.”
A COWPOX CHARLATAN.
Yet, incredible as it may appear, it is with the praise of this
impotent cowpox, attended with no erysipelas, that the public
have been deafened, and for which the most extravagant assertions
are made. Dr. Martin, one of the chief producers and vendors of
the article, appeared at the British Medical Association in 1881,
saying, “I am called upon at times, at the very shortest notice,
to vaccinate whole cities; and when I left America, I had just
completed the vaccination of the city of New Haven. The custom
is to send for me, or my son, wherever smallpox breaks out, with
orders to vaccinate at once the entire population of the city,
town, or neighbourhood. It is done immediately, the result being
that an epidemic is completely stopped in a week.”
Thus spoke the charlatan, with the acquiescence of the medical
assembly. When churchmen deplore the scepticism of the age, and
the decay of faith, it is to be observed that the habit of mind is
limited to certain modes of opinion, and that in general we are
as credulous as ever. Human nature in its structure is curiously
immutable. Wherein is the advantage to disbelieve in witchcraft and
to believe that epidemics of smallpox can be stopped with cowpox?
A DECOROUS UNANIMITY.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account