The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
My inquiry into the nature of the Cowpox commenced upwards of
twenty-five years ago. My attention to this singular disease
was first excited by observing that among those whom in the
country I was frequently called upon to inoculate, many resisted
every effort to give them the Smallpox. These patients I found
had undergone a disease they called the Cowpox, contracted by
milking Cows affected with a peculiar eruption on their teats.
On inquiry, it appeared it had been known among the dairies
from time immemorial, and that a vague opinion prevailed that
it was a preventive of the Smallpox. This opinion I found was
comparatively new among them; for all the older farmers declared
they had no such idea in their early days--a circumstance that
seemed easily to be accounted for, from my knowing that the
common people were very rarely inoculated for the Smallpox
till that practice was rendered general by the improved method
introduced by the Suttons: so that the working people in the
dairies were seldom put to the test of the preventive powers of
the Cowpox.
Jenner’s design in the foregoing statement was manifest. It was to
minimise the faith of the country folk, and to represent that by
his own perspicacity he had discovered the virtue of Cowpox through
his failures to inoculate with Smallpox. The inquiries of Pearson
and others, however, showed conclusively that in many parts of the
south of England, in Ireland, and on the Continent it was believed
that to have suffered from Cowpox was to be secure from Smallpox;
and the belief was entertained altogether independently of failures
to inoculate with Smallpox; just as a similar belief prevailed
among farriers as to the prophylaxy of Horsegrease. The faith
in Cowpox was neither vague, nor new, nor confined to Jenner’s
neighbourhood; and his assertion to the contrary showed with what
hardihood he had undertaken to construct a case in his own favour.
In opposition to the rural faith, medical men maintained that it
was possible to have Smallpox after Cowpox; and surgeons averred
that they had successfully inoculated many who had suffered Cowpox.
Indeed it was indubitable professional testimony to this effect
that compelled Jenner to forsake his first fancy for Cowpox,
and to report the true specific as Horsegrease Cowpox. Having,
however, to sacrifice that discovery, and revert to the Cowpox he
had discredited, a fresh manœuvre was requisite; and thus was it
performed--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account