The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
In this connection the question occurs, Why should “some varieties
of spontaneous eruptions” have been designated _spurious_ Cowpox?
Such eruptions were not Cowpox in any sense. Why then spurious?
That Cows communicated a variety of sores to their milkers,
described by them in common as Cowpox, was an assertion for which
Jenner never adduced any evidence; which, too, (as we shall see)
at a later date he disowned as a misapprehension. Nevertheless
spurious Cowpox got the New Inoculation over many difficulties.
When Smallpox, or any notable mischief, followed Cowpox it was
said, “Ah! the Cowpox must have been spurious; for Smallpox, or
any harm, is impossible after true Cowpox.” People did not stay to
inquire whether spurious Cowpox (that was to say, matter “from a
variety of sores on the Cow,” according to Jenner’s second version)
could be propagated from arm-to-arm, even if taken from the Cow by
mistake. The illusory Variolous Test and the Spurious Cowpox Dodge
worked marvellously for the public deception.
Another point Jenner tried to score at the cost of Pearson and
Woodville. When they began to inoculate they found they had to
ascertain at what period the virus should be taken from the Cow,
and from the arms of the inoculated. Jenner afforded them no
guidance. Writing to John Ring, 1st July, 1801, he confessed--
In the early part of my inoculations I had not learned to
discriminate between the efficacy of the virus taken at an early
and at a late period of the pustule.[125]
Where Jenner had not learned to discriminate, the line became clear
in the course of general practice; and Pearson was especially
explicit as to the right time for taking virus; but to make good
his claim to national consideration, Jenner fancied it necessary
to exhibit himself as complete master of the art of Cowpox
Inoculation, owing nothing to others; and he therefore proceeded to
appropriate the fruit of the common medical experience, assigning
it to a season when he alone was in the field. Referring to his
separation of true from spurious Cowpox, he thus prosecuted his
raid--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account