The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
This impediment to my progress was not long removed before
another, of far greater magnitude in appearance, started up.
There were not wanting instances to prove that when the true
Cowpox broke out among the cattle at a dairy, the person who
had milked an infected animal, and had thereby gone through the
disease in common with others, was liable to receive the Smallpox
afterwards. This, like the former obstacle, gave a painful check
to my fond and aspiring hopes; but reflecting that the operations
of Nature are generally uniform, and that it was not probable the
human constitution (having undergone the Cowpox) should in some
instances be perfectly shielded from the Smallpox, and in many
others remain unprotected, I resumed my labours with redoubled
ardour. The result was fortunate; for I now discovered that the
virus of Cowpox was liable to undergo progressive changes from
the same cause precisely as that of Smallpox, and that when
it was applied to the human skin in its degenerated state, it
would produce the ulcerated effects in as great a degree as when
it was not decomposed, and sometimes far greater; but having
lost its _specific properties_, it was incapable of producing
that change upon the human frame which is requisite to render
it insusceptible of the variolous contagion: so that it became
evident a person might milk a Cow one day, and having caught the
disease, _be for ever secure_; while another person, milking the
same Cow the next day, might feel the influence of the virus in
such a way as to produce a sore, or sores, and, in consequence of
this, might experience an indisposition to a considerable extent;
yet, as has been observed, the specific quality being lost, the
constitution would receive no peculiar impression....
This observation will fully explain the source of those errors
which have been committed by many inoculators of the Cowpox.
Conceiving the whole process to be extremely simple, as not to
admit of a mistake, they have been heedless about the state of
the Vaccine Virus; and finding it limpid, as part of it will
be, even in an advanced state of the pustule, they have felt an
improper confidence, and sometimes mistaken a spurious pustule
for that which possesses the perfect character.
No one apparently thought it worth while to expose the fictitious
character of these statements, invented by Jenner to justify his
pretensions and to baffle objections. Any careful reader of the
_Inquiry_ of 1798, and the _Origin of Vaccine Inoculation_ of 1801,
cannot fail to perceive the radical inconsistency of the earlier
and later narratives, and how a few hasty experiments enveloped in
unverifiable conjecture and gossip, came to be magnified into years
of arduous research.
He wound up his statement with this flourish and prediction--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account