The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
And this coincidently with extensive Vaccination to which
apparently there was no active opposition! We have also to remember
in this connection the statement of Professor Alexander Monro in
1765, that “the inhabitants of Scotland generally have Smallpox
in their infancy or childhood; very few adults being seen in
this disease”; and that in Edinburgh, with conditions strongly
favourable to Smallpox, the mortality from the disease was on an
average little more than a hundred a year. The Edinburgh physicians
knew nothing practically of Vaccination, and we see how the
Surgeons, who did know, shaped their evidence.
The Dublin College of Physicians echoed the fashionable opinion
“that Cowpox Inoculation was safe, and fully answered its purpose.”
They were “willing to allow that doubtful cases had occurred of
Smallpox after Vaccination, but on minute investigation, these
supposed instances originated generally in misrepresentation,
or the difficulty of discriminating between Smallpox and other
eruptions.” Rather awkwardly, seeing how the opposite opinion was
in vogue, they professed their faith in Variolous Inoculation--
The Smallpox is rendered a much less formidable disease in
Ireland by the frequency of Inoculation for it, than in other
parts of His Majesty’s dominions, where prejudices against
Inoculation have prevailed. Hence parents, not unnaturally,
object to the introduction of a new disease, in the shape
of Vaccination, preferring to trust to the practice with the
mildness and safety of which they are well acquainted.
The Dublin College of Surgeons showed themselves more fully
abreast of the time. They had nothing to say for Inoculation, but
testified their confidence in Vaccination, and how its practice was
increasing in Ireland. From 1800 to 1806 a total of 14,335 had been
“inoculated with vaccine infection” at the Dublin institutions, and
many elsewhere--
Cowpox has been found to be a mild disease, and rarely attended
with danger, or any alarming symptom, and _the few cases
of Smallpox which have occurred in Ireland after supposed
Vaccination_, have been satisfactorily proved _to have arisen
from accidental circumstances_.
Arisen from accidental circumstances! Thus was the divine
illumination of experience veiled and denied!
Fortified with this budget of questionable evidence, the Government
proceeded to claim from the House of Commons a second endowment for
Jenner.
FOOTNOTE:
[138] _Review of Report on Vaccination._ By Benjamin Moseley.
London, 1808.
CHAPTER XVI.
JENNER RELIEVED--1807.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account