The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
Where then is the argument for vaccination from the disappearance
of pock-marked faces? When anyone under seventy proceeds to recite
the legend, “There is no use in arguing against vaccination, for
when I was young every third or fourth person was pock-marked,”
etc., etc., the effect is droll. It shows how prone we are to fancy
we have seen what we think we ought to have seen. Droller still it
is when striplings of five-and-twenty and thirty profess the same
experience--“When I was a lad,” and so forth and so forth. There is
matter for reflection as well as for laughter in the hallucination.
Nevertheless, if pock-marked faces are not so common as they must
have been a century ago, they are by no means rare; and if the
argument for vaccination were valid, the pock-marked would be
unvaccinated. But are they? Those who will take pains to inquire
will find that almost invariably they have been vaccinated, and
some of them repeatedly, the vaccination having as it were induced
the smallpox.
VACCINIA A REAL DISEASE.
Thus far we have chiefly dealt with vaccination as if its fault
were limited to failure to prevent smallpox; but vaccination
is more than an ineffective incantation. It is the induction
of an acute specific disease. The prime note of vaccination is
erysipelas. “The cowpox inflammation,” said Jenner, “is always
of the erysipelatous kind.” He held that cowpox unattended with
erysipelas was “incapable of producing any specific effect on the
human constitution.” If it is supposed that Jenner is antiquated,
we may refer to a distinguished contemporary. Mr. John Simon
replying to the question, “Whether properly performed vaccination
is an absolutely inoffensive proceeding?” answers decisively, “Not
at all; nor does it pretend to be so.” The rationale of vaccination
is that it communicates a mild variety of smallpox, and that with
a little of the devil we buy off the entire devil. Dr. Ballard,
Medical Officer to the Local Government Board, in his treatise,
_Vaccination: its Value and Alleged Dangers_, says, “Vaccination
is not a thing to be trifled with, or to be made light of; it is
not to be undertaken thoughtlessly, or without due consideration
of the patient, his mode of life, and the circumstances of season
and of place. Surgeon and patient should both carry in their minds
the regulating thought, that the one is engaged in communicating,
the other in receiving into his system, a _real_ disease--as truly
a disease as smallpox or measles; a disease which, mild and gentle
as its progress may usually be, yet, nevertheless, now and then,
like every other exanthematous malady, asserts its character by an
unusual exhibition of virulence.”
VACCINAL FATALITIES.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account