The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
Whilst Cobbett could not arrest the action of Parliament, he
was short-sighted in considering that the proposed endowment of
vaccination was merely a question of the loss of a few thousands
a year. We are saddled with vaccination at this day, its costs
and mischiefs, by reason of the vote for the National Vaccine
Establishment in 1808. As soon as an annual subsidy is placed on
the estimates, interests are created, which not only perpetuate
themselves, but constantly tend to enlargement; and such interests,
once created, can only be got rid of when proved useless by
agitation out of doors and persistent pressure on the House of
Commons.
Referring to a notorious outbreak of smallpox among a vaccinated
population at Ringwood in Hampshire, Cobbett continued--
I should like to have heard Mr. Rose’s statement of the
circumstances at Ringwood, whence, he says, it is evident that
the failure arose “from the use of _improper matter_.” That many
persons, who had been inoculated with Cowpox, caught Smallpox and
died at Ringwood, is a fact that even the Royal Jennerian Society
cannot deny; and this being the case, what man in his senses
will put any faith in the efficacy of Cowpox as a preventive of
Smallpox? _The thing is done._ It _has failed_, and it is vain to
endeavour to prop up its reputation; for, in a few years, it will
become proverbial as humbug.
A prophecy, it will be said, that has not been fulfilled. True:
but in Cobbett’s time it advanced far to fulfilment. All the
unqualified promises under which vaccination was brought into
practice, were one by one surrendered under the compulsion of
experience. The mass of the people remained unvaccinated; the zeal
for vaccinating the poor abated; and the practice continued among
the middle and upper classes on the humblest pretexts--as something
that might hinder or mitigate smallpox, and in any case do little
harm. We have to recollect that the mania for vaccination which
now prevails is a revival of a prescription which our forefathers
had tested and found wanting. Vaccination fell into neglect, not
because there was indifference to smallpox, but because it did not
prevent that disease.
The excuse for the first failures of vaccination was, that spurious
cowpox must have been employed--spurious cowpox being the artful
invention of Jenner to cover disasters; artful, and yet absurd,
for how could cowpox exist spuriously any more than smallpox? The
precise fact, that spurious cowpox was the dodge of an unscrupulous
quack was unknown to Cobbett, but he was sharp enough to recognise
imposture, and thus wrote--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account