The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters — John Shaqi
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
Nor is the case against vaccination yet complete. The virus used
is not only Vaccinia, but more than Vaccinia; for it is impossible
to propagate virus from child to child without taking up other
qualities. This was clearly foreseen by the variolators when
vaccination was introduced--_they_ making it a point to take
smallpox for inoculation from _known_ and _sound_ subjects. They
maintained that cowpox transferred indiscriminately from arm to
arm _must_ acquire and convey constitutional taints; and their
prognostication was speedily and grievously fulfilled in the item
of syphilis. Notwithstanding, the fact was furiously contested. It
was said that parents used vaccination as a screen for their own
wickedness; and assertion alternated with denial even to our own
day. At last the conflict is at an end. The evidence has grown too
multitudinous and deadly for evasion. The invaccination of syphilis
is admitted, and any question is reserved for the degree of
frequency. Some are pleased to describe the risk as infinitesimal,
but their pleasure stands for nothing but itself. Deeds are
expressive beyond words. The wide resort to animal vaccination on
the Continent and in the United States has but one interpretation.
Doctors and patients do not abandon what is easy for what is
troublesome, nor incur the risk of the communication of bovine
disorders unless under the influence of over-mastering terror.
STATISTICAL EVIDENCE OF EXTRA DISEASE.
Relations of individual experience may be disregarded as
untrustworthy, but the broad evidence of national statistics
conveys authoritative lessons. Vaccination in England was made
compulsory in 1853, stringently so in 1867, and systematically
extended to the entire population. If therefore it were true that
vaccination often communicates more than Vaccinia, and that it
aggravates existent and excites latent disease, the proof must be
manifest in the statistics of the Registrar-General. Thus argued
Mr. C. H. Hopwood, and accordingly he moved in the House of Commons
successively for three Returns, published as follows--VACCINATION,
MORTALITY, No. 433, 1877; MORTALITY (GENERAL AND INFANT), No. 76,
1880; and DEATHS (ENGLAND AND WALES), No. 392, 1880.
These Returns, charged with curious and authentic information,
are little known, and have been treated with significant silence
by the press. Obscurantism is not confined to ecclesiastics. Our
valiant journalists who mock at the Index Expurgatorius, and abhor
the Russian censorship, are in their little way as ready to act the
same part in favour of established prejudice. If facts adverse to
the public confidence in vaccination are revealed, it is considered
no more than decent to keep them out of sight.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account