The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
I have said that the world gave a cordial and unhesitating welcome
to Jenner’s revelation, but the observation requires a startling
qualification. Jenner’s revelation as conveyed in his _Inquiry_
was summarily and ignominiously rejected--was absolutely rejected.
I wish to emphasise this point. Jenner published his _Inquiry_ in
order to recommend horsegrease cowpox, and what I have to say is,
that the public declined to have anything to do with horsegrease
cowpox. The origin of cowpox in horsegrease was scouted as an
intolerable origin. It was disgusting. Why a diseased secretion
from horses’ heels should be more repulsive than a similar
secretion from cows’ teats was not explained; but, as we all know,
there is no accounting for tastes. Various attempts were made to
verify Jenner’s prescription by inoculating cows with horsegrease,
but they ended in failure--fortunately, it was said, in failure;
for as Dr. Pearson (chief among primitive vaccinators) observed,
“The very name of horsegrease was like to have damned the whole
thing.” What did Jenner do under these circumstances? Did he
confront the public and assert the efficacy of horsegrease cowpox?
Not he. He wanted money. He saw how the wind was blowing. He said
not another word about horsegrease cowpox; and as the public
were eager at any price to escape from the nuisance of smallpox
inoculation, and disposed to substitute cowpox as a harmless
substitute, why then he resolved to go in for cowpox, and pose as
its discoverer and promoter.
JENNER’S TRANSFORMATION.
I am not making what is called a constructive charge against
Jenner, but simply setting forth plain, undeniable matter-of-fact.
I ask any one in doubt as to what I say to read Jenner’s _Inquiry_,
published in 1798, the prescription of which is horsegrease cowpox,
and the condemnation of cowpox. Turn then to his petition for
largess, addressed to the House of Commons in 1802, and what do we
find? Not one word about horsegrease cowpox, but this audacious
assertion:--
“That your Petitioner has discovered that a disease which
occasionally exists in a particular form among cattle, known by
name of Cowpox, admits of being inoculated on the human frame
with the most perfect ease and safety, and is attended with the
singularly beneficial effect of rendering through life the person
so inoculated perfectly secure from the infection of Smallpox.”
Why, that was not Jenner’s discovery! It was the notion of the
dairymaids, and, so far as concerned spontaneous cowpox, was known
by Jenner to be untrue. Yet, strange to say, the claim was in a
measure allowed by the House of Commons, and £10,000 awarded to the
imposter, and subsequently £20,000 in 1807.
HORSEGREASE COWPOX KEPT OUT OF SIGHT.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account