The Story of Lewis Carroll: Told for Young People by the Real Alice in Wonderland — John Shaqi
The Story of Lewis Carroll: Told for Young People by the Real Alice in WonderlandBowman, Isa
History
The Story of Lewis Carroll: Told for Young People by the Real Alice in Wonderland
Bowman, Isa
Authors, English -- 19th century -- Biography -- Juvenile literature; Carroll, Lewis, 1832-1898 -- Juvenile literature
"MY LORD DUKE,--The photographs, which Your Grace did me the honour of
sending arrived safely; and I can assure your Royal Highness that I am
very glad to have them, and like them _very_ much, particularly the
large head of your late Royal Uncle's little little son. I do not
wonder that your excellent Uncle Richard should say 'off with his
head!' as a hint to the photographer to print it off. Would your
Highness like me to go on calling you the Duke of York, or shall I say
'my own own darling Isa?' Which do you like best?
"Now I'm going to find fault with my pet about her acting. What's the
good of an old Uncle like me except to find fault?
"You do the meeting with the Prince of Wales _very_ nicely and
lovingly; and, in teasing your Uncle for his dagger and his sword, you
are very sweet and playful and--'but _that's_ not finding fault!' Isa
says to herself. Isn't it? Well, I'll try again. Didn't I hear you say
'In weightier things you'll say a _beggar_ nay,' leaning on the word
'beggar'? If so, it was a mistake. _My_ rule for knowing which word to
lean on is the word that tells you something _new_, something that is
_different_ from what you expected.
"Take the sentence 'first I bought a bag of apples, then I bought a
bag of pears,' you wouldn't say 'then I bought a _bag_ of pears.' The
'bag' is nothing new, because it was a bag in the first part of the
sentence. But the _pears_ are new, and different from the _apples_.
So you would say, 'then I bought a bag of _pears_.'
"Do you understand that, my pet?"
"Now what you say to Richard amounts to this, 'With light gifts you'll
say to a beggar "yes": with heavy gifts you'll say to a beggar "nay."'
The words 'you'll say to a beggar' are the same both times; so you
mustn't lean on any of _those_ words. But 'light' is different from
'heavy,' and 'yes' is different from 'nay.' So the way to say the
sentence would be 'with _light_ gifts you'll say to a beggar "_yes_":
with _heavy_ gifts you'll say to a beggar "_nay_".' And the way to say
the lines in the play is--
'O, then I see you will _part_ but with _light_ gifts;
In _weightier_ things you'll say a beggar _nay_.'
"One more sentence.
"When Richard says, 'What, would you have my _weapon_, little Lord?'
and you reply 'I _would_, that I might thank you as you call me,'
didn't I hear you pronounce 'thank' as if it were spelt with an 'e'? I
know it's very common (I often do it myself) to say 'thenk you!' as an
exclamation by itself. I suppose it's an odd way of pronouncing the
word. But I'm sure it's wrong to pronounce it so when it comes into a
_sentence_. It will sound _much_ nicer if you'll pronounce it so as to
rhyme with 'bank.'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account