The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & ExperiencesDenison, George T. (George Taylor)
History
The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & Experiences
Denison, George T. (George Taylor)
Canada -- History -- 1867-1914
If the Imperial Government proposes, as the report indicates, to
enlist a number of units of one hundred and twenty-five men each, to
be attached to the British Infantry Regiments, and to be paid and
maintained at imperial expense, there can be no objection raised to
their doing it, in any way they like, and under any conditions that
may be agreed upon between the imperial authorities and the Canadians
who enlist in what will practically be British regiments. Of course,
these units will not be a Canadian contingent, any more than were
the 40,000 Canadians who fought in the northern army during the civil
war, or the large numbers who fought in the ranks of the United States
army and navy in the late Spanish war. A thousand Canadians may go
and fight for the Empire in the British army, but it will not be a
Canadian contingent, nor will it represent Canadian sentiment, or a
Canadian desire to aid the Empire. For what part will the six millions
who stay at home contribute to that contingent?
If Canada sends a contingent as her share in helping the common cause,
she should send a force commanded by our own officers, and paid and
maintained by our own people. They should feel that they represent
our country, and that the honour of all who stay at home is in their
keeping. Men would go in such a corps for such a purpose who would
never dream of enlisting as the ordinary Tommy Atkins, in regiments
they did not know, among comrades unfamiliar, and under strange
officers. A Canadian contingent sent to represent our militia and
country in an imperial quarrel would attract the very best of our
young men, but every officer should be a Canadian.
The slurs that have been thrown out in some quarters, that our
officers are not qualified, are not based upon fact, and are grossly
insulting to our people. We have had over 35,000 militia for over
thirty years, we have had a Military College of the highest class
for over twenty years, a permanent corps for over fifteen years, a
number of our officers have been sent for long courses of instruction
at Aldershot, and not long since 6,000 of our militia were engaged
in a campaign of some four months' duration. If Canada with all that
experience has not produced one man fit to command a battalion of
infantry, we are too inferior a type of fellaheen to offer assistance
to anyone. I repudiate, however, any such idea of inferiority. It does
not exist, and even if it did, our own Government should not admit it
until it has been clearly proven.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account