The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & ExperiencesDenison, George T. (George Taylor)
History
The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & Experiences
Denison, George T. (George Taylor)
Canada -- History -- 1867-1914
It has been said that our men have not had war service, and that a
lieutenant-colonel in command of a battalion in war must have war
experience. I examined the list of imperial battalions published in
this evening's _Telegram_, as being in South Africa, or told off
to be sent there, and I find, after consulting Hart's army list,
that out of these thirty-four battalions seventeen are commanded by
lieutenant-colonels who have had war service, and the same number
by lieutenant-colonels who have never had experience of any kind in
active operations. An examination of our militia list of the 1st April
last shows that in the seniority lists of lieutenant-colonels there
are no less than seventy-six who have the crossed swords before their
names, indicating that they have had active service. It seems strange
that out of the seventy-six one could not be found sufficiently
qualified. Let us send a Canadian contingent entirely our own, and at
our own cost. Let us send the best we have, and then let us stand or
fall with what they can do on our behalf. I think we can await the
result with confidence.
Sir Wilfrid Laurier read this letter the same evening, and wrote me at
once, asking me to do nothing further on that line, but to meet him
at Sir Wm. Mulock's at ten p.m. on Monday evening, the 16th, on his
arrival from Bowmanville, and he asked me to get Mr. Willison to come
also.
On the Monday afternoon the evening papers published a despatch from
Ottawa, saying that the British Government had agreed to change their
order, and allow the contingent to go as a unit under a Canadian
officer. When I met Sir Wilfrid he told me he had received a telegram
at Bowmanville to that effect, but was surprised to hear that it had
got into the newspapers. He then told me that he had cabled to England
on the Saturday evening, the 14th, and had urged strongly that our men
should be sent as one corps, and that it had been agreed to. Once more
I was under obligations as a Canadian to Sir Wilfrid Laurier, in his
efforts to maintain the dignity of Canada. The feeling here was that
the dividing up our force into companies attached to British regiments
was the idea of General Hutton, who had the regular officer's view
as to the lack of capacity of colonial militia. The three years' war
which followed, with colonial forces side by side with imperial troops,
pretty effectually settled the question whether the colonial levies
were inferior or not to any of their comrades.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account