The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & ExperiencesDenison, George T. (George Taylor)
History
The Struggle for Imperial Unity: Recollections & Experiences
Denison, George T. (George Taylor)
Canada -- History -- 1867-1914
The meeting of the Congress of Chambers of Commerce of the Empire
took place on the 10th, 11th and 13th July. We had but little hope
of doing anything to help the preferential trade policy, for the
General Elections had gone so overwhelmingly against us that it seemed
impossible that in England our Canadian delegation could carry the
resolution they had agreed upon in favour of Mr. Chamberlain's policy.
We expected to be badly defeated, but decided to make a bold fight.
After the discussion had gone on for some time, Sir Wm. Holland and
Lord Avebury, who led the free trade ranks, approached Mr. Drummond,
who had moved the Canadian resolution, and suggested that if we would
compromise by the insertion of a few words which would have destroyed
the whole effect of what we were fighting for, the resolution might
be carried unanimously. Mr. Drummond said he wished to consult his
colleagues, and he called Mr. Cockshutt, M.P., and me out of the room
and put the proposition. I said at once, "I would not compromise to the
extent of one word. Let us fight it out to the very end, let us take
a vote. We will likely be beaten, but let us take our beating like
men. We will find out our strength and our weakness, we will find out
who are our friends and who are our enemies, and know exactly where we
stand."
Mr. Cockshutt said immediately, "I entirely agree with Denison."
Drummond said, "That is exactly my view. I shall consult with no others
but will tell them we will fight it to the end."
I spoke that afternoon as follows as reported in the Toronto _News_,
23rd August, 1906:
There were a few remarks, said Col. Denison, which had fallen from
previous speakers, to which he desired to call attention. In the
first place, his friend Mr. Cockshutt, said that Canada had given
England the benefit of five million dollars annually in the reduction
of duties, in order to help the English manufacturer to sell English
manufactured goods in Canada, and stated that that was a contribution
in an indirect way towards helping the defence of the Empire. Mr.
Cockshutt, however, left out one important point. If Canada had put
that tax on, collected the money, and handed over the five million
dollars to England in hard cash, what would have been the result? The
greater portion of the trade would have gone to Germany, would have
given work to German workmen, would have helped to build German ships,
and it would have taken more than the five million dollars annually
to counterbalance the loss thereby caused to this country. He felt
that every day the British people were allowing the greatest national
trade asset that any nation ever possessed, the markets of Great
Britain, to be exposed to the free attack of every rival manufacturing
nation in the world without any protection, without any possibility
of preserving those great national assets for the use of their own
people, and in his opinion such a policy was exceedingly foolish.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account