The Sun changes its position in space: therefore it cannot be regarded as being "in a condition of rest"Tischner, August
History
The Sun changes its position in space: therefore it cannot be regarded as being "in a condition of rest"
Tischner, August
Solar system -- Miscellanea
Astronomical science, at the present day insists upon the system of
Copernicus, which, as is well known, is based upon the theory _of a
fixed sun_, and remains convinced of the incontrovertible truth and
importance of this system, even after it has become an incontestable
fact, that the sun changes its position; endeavouring to explain away
this discrepancy by the sophism, that the sun may be considered as _in a
condition of rest_. But the smallest movement of the sun overthrows the
entire fabric of Copernicus. Unless we take into account the
observations, made for the last 3000 years, respecting the movement of
the sun in space, it is impossible to comprehend the solar system and
its movements. Theory must take notice of the phenomena of the sun's own
movement and dare not cloak it under imaginary causes; for so long as
the motion of the sun is ignored, it is impossible to know thoroughly
the motion of the earth which follows it, and if the motion of the earth
be not known, it is also impossible to know the motion of the other
heavenly bodies, belonging to the solar system, as seen from the earth.
In a word, the astronomical theory, as it is now generally accepted and
believed to be the only and doubtless true, is wholly untenable,
requiring _a total and essential_ reformation; astronomical authors
cling to J. H. Mädler's assertion, that every body will understand the
impossibility for an astronomer of our time to enter upon any other
system even by way of trial.
If this theory be converted into a _dogma_, stagnation must commence and
all progress becomes impossible. In the history of science and its
advance, we find that there have been at all times new theories
propounded, which had often to be changed later on, or even set aside by
others diametrically opposite. The principal circumstance which renders
the system of Copernicus impossible, is that the orbits of the planets
_are considered as closed curves around the sun_. This view has
frequently been attacked; but it is maintained by astronomers, as it is
requisite for the elucidation of the system. Still it is evident that if
the centre of attraction moves forward the bodies attracted by it
_cannot move around it_.
Let us examine the system of Copernicus. Ptolemæus first introduced his
system among the ancients. The earth was the fixed centre of the world
and around it moved the moon, the sun, the planets and the stars. This
system lasted for XV centuries.
The Ptolemaic system was modified by Copernicus, and the system of
Copernicus was simply the inversion of the Ptolemaic. The sun took the
place of the earth. In the centre was a fixed point (earth or sun),
around which the planets moved in larger or smaller orbits.
The main feature of both systems is that one of the heavenly bodies is
_stationary, in order that the others may travel round it_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account