The taste of honey : $b The note book of a linguist — John Shaqi
The taste of honey : $b The note book of a linguistUnderwood, Edna Worthley
History
The taste of honey : $b The note book of a linguist
Underwood, Edna Worthley
Literature -- History and criticism
Traveling once—when I was young—in the South West, near the Rio
Grande, I met on a night train into some hot, lonely city, a homesick
old man who spoke Spanish. His clothing indicated poverty. In his
pocket he had a piece of dirty paper upon which he had copied down
a poem, which he kept reading over and over. And sometimes when he
read, he cried. I was puzzled. After awhile I told him I could read
Spanish, and asked to see it. It was _The Nocturn_—before it had ever
been printed. How I wish I had asked him about Silvá, and why he
cried! (Many disputed editions of it exist today, because not so long
after this, Silvá killed himself.) My translation was approved by
English reading, Spanish and French critics, but Americans had little
interest in it. None of them had heard of Silvá; and fewer knew
that his poem was one of the greatest written on the Twin Americas.
Later—some years—the _Mercure de France_ sent a representative all
the way to Colombia, to gain information about the life of Silvá.
To the United States he still remains _terra ignota_. The greatest
critics of the Continent have raved over this one exquisite creation
of Silvá, the great Colombian. Silvá was the first of the new and the
last of the old. Pedro-Emilio Coll declared he had never met a more
comprehensive intelligence, nor one more hospitable to every phase of
thought.
Years later, going up the pea-soup-hued, gloomy, shadowed Magdalena
River in Colombia, it was not the strangely engaging tropic world
about me that I thought of, but Silvá, exquisite creator, who like
Catullus, died in his youth. In my heart, to him I was saying ...
_Hail! And farewell._
It is a peculiar thing that Mrs. Asquith should write. It is
something for which she has no ability. In her case it is one of
the multiple shadows of conceit, too long, too unearned material
well-being. She has nothing to say. And she does not know how to say
nothing well.
Frequently she seems ungrammatical. Her power is personality, speech;
_nerve_. Another example of _Mr. Phinney’s Turnip_ growing beyond its
boundaries, in a period of time made for turnips. Only an age when
art is dying could have printed her. But when the house threatens to
fall, who can prophecy what will rush in!
In reading her books I do not recall finding one commanding idea,
sentence, not to mention beauty of any kind. In print her mind is
harsh, cruel, insensitive. One does not see the majestic moving
forward of that which charms, interests.
But such writing from England as Charles M. Doughty did makes up for
what Mrs. Asquith has inflicted upon a helpless public. How glorious
is this from Doughty’s _Arabia_:
“This vast Arabian upland is, in a word, a seered and wasteful
wilderness full of fear, where every man’s hand is ready against
another; a lean, wild, grit and dust, stiffened with everlasting
drouth, where running water lacks, and whose sun-stricken face
is seamed from of old, here and there, with shallow, dry water
courses....”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account