Subordinate to these reasons for studying geometry are many others,
exactly as with all other subjects of the curriculum. Geometry, for
example, offers the best developed application of logic that we have, or
are likely to have, in the school course. This does not mean that it
always exemplifies perfect logic, for it does not; but to the pupil who
is not ready for logic, per se, it offers an example of close reasoning
such as his other subjects do not offer. We may say, and possibly with
truth, that one who studies geometry will not reason more clearly on a
financial proposition than one who does not; but in spite of the results
of the very meager experiments of the psychologists, it is probable that
the man who has had some drill in syllogisms, and who has learned to
select the essentials and to neglect the nonessentials in reaching his
conclusions, has acquired habits in reasoning that will help him in
every line of work. As part of this equipment there is also a terseness
of statement and a clearness in arrangement of points in an argument
that has been the subject of comment by many writers.
Upon this same topic an English writer, in one of the sanest of recent
monographs upon the subject,[13] has expressed his views in the
following words:
The statement that a given individual has received a sound
geometrical training implies that he has segregated from the
whole of his sense impressions a certain set of these
impressions, that he has then eliminated from their
consideration all irrelevant impressions (in other words,
acquired a subjective command of these impressions), that he
has developed on the basis of these impressions an ordered and
continuous system of logical deduction, and finally that he is
capable of expressing the nature of these impressions and his
deductions therefrom in terms simple and free from ambiguity.
Now the slightest consideration will convince any one not
already conversant with the idea, that the same sequence of
mental processes underlies the whole career of any individual
in any walk of life if only he is not concerned entirely with
manual labor; consequently a full training in the performance
of such sequences must be regarded as forming an essential part
of any education worthy of the name. Moreover, the full
appreciation of such processes has a higher value than is
contained in the mental training involved, great though this
be, for it induces an appreciation of intellectual unity and
beauty which plays for the mind that part which the
appreciation of schemes of shape and color plays for the
artistic faculties; or, again, that part which the appreciation
of a body of religious doctrine plays for the ethical
aspirations. Now geometry is not the sole possible basis for
inculcating this appreciation. Logic is an alternative for
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account