The distinctive feature of Euclid's "Elements," compared with the modern
American textbook, is perhaps this: Euclid begins a book with what seems
to him the easiest proposition, be it theorem or problem; upon this he
builds another; upon these a third, and so on, concerning himself but
little with the classification of propositions. Furthermore, he arranges
his propositions so as to construct his figures before using them. We,
on the other hand, make some little attempt to classify our propositions
within each book, and we make no attempt to construct our figures before
using them, or at least to prove that the constructions are correct.
Indeed, we go so far as to study the properties of figures that we
cannot construct, as when we ask for the size of the angle of a regular
heptagon. Thus Euclid begins Book I by a problem, to construct an
equilateral triangle on a given line. His object is to follow this by
problems on drawing a straight line equal to a given straight line, and
cutting off from the greater of two straight lines a line equal to the
less. He now introduces a theorem, which might equally well have been
his first proposition, namely, the case of the congruence of two
triangles, having given two sides and the included angle. By means of
his third and fourth propositions he is now able to prove the _pons
asinorum_, that the angles at the base of an isosceles triangle are
equal. We, on the other hand, seek to group our propositions where this
can conveniently be done, putting the congruent propositions together,
those about inequalities by themselves, and the propositions about
parallels in one set. The results of the two arrangements are not
radically different, and the effect of either upon the pupil's mind does
not seem particularly better than that of the other. Teachers who have
used both plans quite commonly feel that, apart from Books II and V,
Euclid is nearly as easily understood as our modern texts, if presented
in as satisfactory dress.
The topics treated and the number of propositions in the plane geometry
of the "Elements" are as follows:
Book I. Rectilinear figures 48
Book II. Geometric algebra 14
Book III. Circles 37
Book IV. Problems about circles 16
Book V. Proportion 25
Book VI. Applications of proportion 33
----
173
Of these we now omit Euclid's Book II, because we have an algebraic
symbolism that was unknown in his time, although he would not have used
it in geometry even had it been known. Thus his first proposition in
Book II is as follows:
If there be two straight lines, and one of them be cut into any
number of segments whatever, the rectangle contained by the two
straight lines is equal to the rectangles contained by the
uncut straight line and each of the segments.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account