The treatise of Lorenzo Valla on the Donation of ConstantineValla, Lorenzo
History
The treatise of Lorenzo Valla on the Donation of Constantine
Valla, Lorenzo
Church and state -- Holy Roman Empire; Constitutum Constantini; Popes -- Temporal power -- Early works to 1800
“And at the same time the tiara and also the shoulder-band,—that is the
strap that usually surrounds our imperial neck.” Who ever heard “tiara”
[phrygium] used in Latin? You talk like a barbarian and want it to seem
to me to be a speech of Constantine’s or of Lactantius’. Plautus, in the
Menaechmi, applied “phrygionem” to a designer of garments; Pliny calls
clothes embroidered with a needle “phrygiones” because the Phrygians
invented them; but what does “phrygium” mean? You do not explain
this, which is obscure; you explain what is quite clear. You say the
“shoulder-band” is a “strap,” and you do not perceive what the strap
is, for you do not visualize a leather band, which we call a strap,
encircling the Caesar’s neck as an ornament. [It is of leather], hence we
call harness and whips “straps”: but if ever gold straps are mentioned,
it can only be understood as applying to gilt harness such as is put
around the neck of a horse or of some other animal. But this has escaped
your notice, I think. So when you wish to put a strap around the Caesar’s
neck, or Sylvester’s, you change a man, an Emperor, a supreme pontiff,
into a horse or an ass.
“And also the purple mantle and scarlet tunic.” Because Matthew says “a
scarlet robe,” and John “a purple robe,”[473] this fellow tries to join
them together in the same passage. But if they are the same color, as
the Evangelists imply, why are you not content, as they were, to name
either one alone; unless, like ignorant folk today, you use “purple”
for silk goods of a whitish color? The “purple” [pupura], however, is
a fish in whose blood wool is dyed, and so from the dye the name has
been given to the cloth, whose color can be called red, though it may
rather be blackish and very nearly the color of clotted blood, a sort of
violet. Hence by Homer and Virgil blood is called purple, as is porphyry,
the color of which is similar to amethyst; for the Greeks call purple
“porphyra.” You know perhaps that scarlet is used for red; but I would
swear that you do not know at all why he makes it “coccineum” when we say
“coccum,” or what sort of a garment a “mantle” [chlamys] is.
But that he might not betray himself as a liar by continuing longer
on the separate garments, he embraced them all together in a single
word, saying, “all the imperial raiment.” What! even that which he is
accustomed to wear in war, in the chase, at banquets, in games? What
could be more stupid than to say that all the raiment of the Caesar
befits a pontiff!
But how gracefully he adds, “and the same rank as those presiding over
the imperial cavalry.” He says “seu” [“or” for “and”].[474] He wishes to
distinguish between these two in turn, as if they were very like each
other, and slips along from the imperial raiment to the equestrian rank,
saying—I know not what! He wants to say something wonderful, but fears to
be caught lying, and so with puffed cheeks and swollen throat, he gives
forth sound without sense.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account