The treatise of Lorenzo Valla on the Donation of ConstantineValla, Lorenzo
History
The treatise of Lorenzo Valla on the Donation of Constantine
Valla, Lorenzo
Church and state -- Holy Roman Empire; Constitutum Constantini; Popes -- Temporal power -- Early works to 1800
However, in this my first discourse I do not wish to urge princes and
peoples to restrain the Pope in his unbridled course as he roams about,
and compel him to stay within bounds, but only to warn him, and perhaps
he has already learned the truth, to betake himself from others’ houses
to his own, and to put to port before the raging billows and savage
tempests. But if he refuses, then I will have recourse to another
discourse far bolder than this.[532] If only I may sometime see, and
indeed I can scarcely wait to see it, especially if it is brought about
by my counsel, if only I may see the time when the Pope is the vicar of
Christ alone, and not of Caesar also! If only there would no longer be
heard the fearful cry, “Partisans for the Church,” “Partisans against the
Church,” “The Church against the Perugians,” “against the Bolognese”!
It is not the church, but the Pope, that fights against Christians; the
church fights against “spiritual wickedness in high places.”[533] Then
the Pope will be the Holy Father in fact as well as in name, Father of
all, Father of the church; nor will he stir up wars among Christians, but
those stirred up by others he, through his apostolic judgment and papal
prerogative, will stop.[534]
FOOTNOTES
[411] The meaning of this word in this connection is unknown. The
chapters to which it is prefixed are for the most part supposed to have
been early marginal annotations afterwards incorporated in the text of
the Decretum. Cf. Friedberg, Corpus Iuris Canonici, vol. I, Prolegomena,
p. lxxxvi.
[412] The subject of chapters xi and xii is, “The Emperors must be under
the Pontiffs, not over them.” Chapters xiii and xiv continue the same
subject.
[413] _retro_ was used at Rome in the latter part of the eighth century
with the peculiar meaning of “still” or “again.” This is one of the
clues to the date and place of the document. Henderson’s translation is
erroneous.
[414] Ps. cxxxix, 7.
[415] I Tim. v, 20.
[416] Valla’s error for Marcellinus. The whole story is apocryphal.
[417] A reference to the reforming councils of the fifteenth century.
[418] Valla was in the service of the king of Sicily and of Naples when
he wrote this.
[419] The phrase “Italy and the western provinces,” in the Donation of
Constantine, meant to the writer of that document the Italian peninsula,
including Lombardy, Venetia, Istria, and adjacent islands. Other
countries probably did not occur to him as part of the Roman Empire.
Valla, however, followed the current interpretation.
[420] In many versions of the Life of Sylvester there is a marvellous
story of an enormous serpent, finally subdued by the saint. Cf. _infra_,
p. 143; Coleman, Constantine the Great and Christianity, pp. 161 _et
seq._; Mombritius, Sanctuarium, Sive Vitae collectae ex codibus (Milan,
_c._ 1479), v, ii, pp. 279 _et seq._, also Paris edition, 1910. For the
story of Bel and the Dragon, cf. the book of that name in the Apocrypha.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account