The Treatment of Hay Fever by rosin-weed, ichthyol and faradic electricity: With a discussion of the old theory of gout and the new theory of anaphylaxisLaidlaw, George Frederick
Science
The Treatment of Hay Fever by rosin-weed, ichthyol and faradic electricity: With a discussion of the old theory of gout and the new theory of anaphylaxis
Laidlaw, George Frederick
Hay fever
=Uricacidæmia and Gout.= Now, why do I speak with respect of de Mussy's
theory of gout as a cause of hay fever and so disrespectfully of the
uric acid doctrine? Are not gout and uric acid poisoning the same thing?
No. They are not; though the two ideas are usually confused by medical
men since Garrod's time and his demonstration of the increase and
decrease of uric acid in the blood of gouty patients. Gout is something
more than a simple accumulation of uric acid in the blood because of its
imperfect elimination by the kidneys. What that something is, we do not
know; but gout is, at least, a clinical entity, a definite group of
symptoms known since Hippocrates' time. Take away the uric acid theory
and you still have the disease, gout, that any of us can recognize, as
the Greeks and Romans recognized it when the word uric acid was unknown.
It is on these symptoms of gout, the clinical picture of disease, not on
any hypothetical uric acid, that de Mussy based his theory and thus far
he is on solid ground. On the other hand, _uric acid poisoning_ is
largely a figment of the imagination. Take away the uric acid, which has
never been satisfactorily proved to be there, and there is nothing left.
In not one one-hundredth part of the cases of so-called uric acid
poisoning is it proved that uric acid has anything to do with the case.
=The Deposits of Uric Acid in Gout.= The deposit of uric acid in the form
of urates in the gouty joint has always been a strong argument for the
theory that gout, at least, is due to an excess of uric acid (urates)
in the blood. At one time, in a humble way, I was a pathologist, and
this theory of a blood overloaded with uric acid as the only thinkable
cause of its deposition in the joints never impressed me as
pathologically sound. I often compared these deposits of urates in the
joints with the deposits of lime salts so often found at autopsies in
caseous glands or small necrotic areas. The superficial observer says:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account