The Treatment of Hay Fever by rosin-weed, ichthyol and faradic electricity: With a discussion of the old theory of gout and the new theory of anaphylaxisLaidlaw, George Frederick
Science
The Treatment of Hay Fever by rosin-weed, ichthyol and faradic electricity: With a discussion of the old theory of gout and the new theory of anaphylaxis
Laidlaw, George Frederick
Hay fever
This is the old, old experiment that has been tried so many times in
many diseases and has so often failed. It reminds us of the many
attempts to confer on the tuberculosis patient the natural immunity
possessed by the jackass by injecting the patient with the blood serum
of that friend of man. The result of these experiments left some doubt
as to who merited most the name of jackass, the doctor, the patient or
the patient beast. Both pollantin and graminol have been praised highly
in Germany but neither of them have succeeded so well in this country.
Perhaps a shrewd advertising campaign had something to do with it; for
the combination of a German scientist and his manufacturer can give
points to any Yankee in exploiting the public with sure cures for the
sick.
=Active Immunity.= In active immunization, the real pioneers, after
Mithridates, were the homoeopaths, who, for many years, have given
small doses of poison ivy to prevent ivy poisoning and small doses of
the poisons of infectious diseases to prevent and cure those diseases;
but the homoeopath did not realize the transient nature of immunity
and the necessity for continuing the treatment for many months or years,
nor did he adopt the principle of increasing the dose to the point of
toleration.
The first to attempt active immunization and cure of hay fever by
injecting extracts of the pollen that causes the disease appears to have
been Noon, working in Wright's laboratory in London. The work was
continued by Freeman, their work being reported in the _Lancet_, 1911,
i, page 1572 and ii, page 814. They found the English spring form of hay
fever due to the pollen of grasses. By dropping extracts of various
pollens into the patient's eye, after the manner of Dunbar, they
concluded that their patients were most sensitive to timothy grass and
they used timothy extract exclusively in the treatment. Freeman states
explicitly that a patient immunized against timothy grass is immune to
all other grasses of that season; that it is unnecessary to immunize
him to each particular grass, thus differing from some of our American
observers who use the skin reaction to determine the particular pollens
to which the patient is sensitive and inject every one of those pollens
in the treatment.
Independently of these British observers, Karl Koessler, of Chicago, in
1910, attempted to immunize patients against hay fever by injecting
pollen extracts. Like Noon and Freeman, he used the eye reaction to test
his patients and found them most sensitive to rag weed. Just as the
Englishmen had used only timothy grass in their cases, Koessler used rag
weed exclusively. His work is reported in his article on Hay Fever in
Forchheimer's _Therapeusis_, Volume V and also in the _Illinois Medical
Journal_, 1914, page 120.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account