In considering this phase of the credibility of the Gospel writers, it
must again be remembered that the question of inspiration has no place
in this discussion; and that Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John must be
regarded simply as secular historians. The reader is urged to consider
the biographers of the Christ as he would consider ordinary witnesses in
a court of law; to apply to them the same tests of credibility; to sift
and weigh their testimony in the same manner; and to subject them to the
same rules of cross-examination. If this is done, it is felt that the
result will be entirely favorable to the veracity and integrity of the
sacred writers.
In considering the subject of discrepancies it should be constantly kept
in mind that contradictions in testimony do not necessarily mean that
there has been falsehood or bad faith on the part of the witnesses.
Every lawyer of experience and every adult citizen of average
intelligence knows that this is true. Men of unquestioned veracity and
incorruptible integrity are frequently arrayed against each other in
both civil and criminal trials, and the record reveals irreconcilable
contradictions in their testimony. Not only do prosecutions for perjury
not follow, but, in many instances, the witnesses are not even suspected
of bad faith or an intention to falsify. Defects in sight, hearing, or
memory; superior advantage in the matter of observation; or a sudden
change in the position of one or both the parties, causing distraction
of attention, at the time of the occurrence of the events involved in
litigation--all or any of these conditions, as well as many others, may
create discrepancies and contradictions where there is a total absence
of any intention to misrepresent. A thorough appreciation of this fact
will greatly aid in a clear understanding of this phase of the
discussion.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account