The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior Analysis — John Shaqi
The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior AnalysisThomas, William Isaac
Science
The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior Analysis
Thomas, William Isaac
Female juvenile delinquents -- Case studies; Young women
Having learned from Doctor Healy the relation between mental conflict
and misconduct and the possibility of cure by the freeing of blocked
emotion, social workers were somewhat prepared for one of the unusual
situations brought about by the war,—namely, the wholesale arrests of
girls and women on suspicion of venereal disease, with effort on the
part of the government not only to cure the physical disease but to
rehabilitate the individual. The gathering of data by the Girls’
Protective Bureau of the United States Interdepartmental Social Hygiene
Board gave a basis for study which years of private practice or
philanthropy could not assemble. One felt about these young prostitutes
that mere suppression by force would not reach the root of the
matter,—that causes and conditions must be studied. With this in mind
certain lines of research were undertaken, primarily to gather and
interpret data which would lead to less unjust treatment than is at
present accorded so-called delinquent women, by changing public opinion
and especially altering procedure in our courts, jails and hospitals. It
was hoped that such data might also tend toward a better understanding
of human relations and indicate marriage standards based upon biology
and psychology rather than on economics.
A profound statement of Mr. Thomas’s is, “Statistics in themselves are
nothing more than the symptoms of unknown causal processes. A social
institution can be understood and modified only if we do not limit
ourselves to the study of its formal organization but analyze the way in
which it appears in the personal experience of various members of the
group and follow the influence it has on their lives.” It was just the
sudden knowledge of the effect of our custom, law and court procedure as
they influenced the lives of individual girls which brought critical
questioning of such justice as had been meted out to them. It seemed as
if society had been systematically wrecking women.
The government program acted as a searchlight flashed upon the farce of
our dual system of morality. In the case of a child suffering assault or
rape she might be detained in an old type of reform school till her
majority gave her freedom—a poor preparation for later life—while the
man, were he convicted, rarely had a long sentence. Of two parents of a
child conceived out of wedlock, for the girl abortion is classed as
crime; motherhood brings shame and condemnation; while the part of the
man passes as a biological necessity. Whereas in some hospitals fifty
per cent of the women arrested on suspicion of disease were found to be
not infected, it was suggested in one city that prophylactic stations be
established in men’s clubs and even in boys’ schools,—the futility of
fine and jail for the woman, freedom for the man.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account