The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior AnalysisThomas, William Isaac
Science
The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior Analysis
Thomas, William Isaac
Female juvenile delinquents -- Case studies; Young women
In addition to the family we have the community as a defining agency. At
present the community is so weak and vague that it gives us no idea of
the former power of the local group in regulating behavior. Originally
the community was practically the whole world of its members. It was
composed of families related by blood and marriage and was not so large
that all the members could not come together; it was a face-to-face
group. I asked a Polish peasant what was the extent of an “_okolica_” or
neighborhood—how far it reached. “It reaches,” he said, “as far as the
report of a man reaches—as far as a man is talked about.” And it was in
communities of this kind that the moral code which we now recognize as
valid originated. The customs of the community are “folkways”, and both
state and church have in their more formal codes mainly recognized and
incorporated these folkways.
The typical community is vanishing and it would be neither possible nor
desirable to restore it in its old form. It does not correspond with the
present direction of social evolution and it would now be a distressing
condition in which to live. But in the immediacy of relationships and
the participation of everybody in everything, it represents an element
which we have lost and which we shall probably have to restore in some
form of coöperation in order to secure a balanced and normal
society,—some arrangement corresponding with human nature.
Very elemental examples of the definition of the situation by the
community as a whole, corresponding to mob action as we know it and to
our trial by jury, are found among European peasants. The three
documents following, all relating to the Russian community or _mir_,
give some idea of the conditions under which a whole community, a
public, formerly defined a situation.
25. We who are unacquainted with peasant speech, manners and method
of expressing thought—mimicry—if we should be present at a division
of land or some settlement among the peasants, would never
understand anything. Hearing fragmentary, disconnected exclamations,
endless quarreling, with repetition of some single word; hearing
this racket of a seemingly senseless, noisy crowd that counts up or
measures off something, we should conclude that they would not get
together, or arrive at any result in an age.... Yet wait until the
end and you will see that the division has been made with
mathematical accuracy—that the measure, the quality of the soil, the
slope of the field, the distance from the village—everything in
short has been taken into account, that the reckoning has been
correctly done and, what is most important, that every one of those
present who were interested in the division is certain of the
correctness of the division or settlement. The cry, the noise, the
racket do not subside until every one is satisfied and no doubter is
left.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account