The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior AnalysisThomas, William Isaac
Science
The Unadjusted Girl, With Cases and Standpoint for Behavior Analysis
Thomas, William Isaac
Female juvenile delinquents -- Case studies; Young women
30. [My daughter has married an Italian who is a very good man]....
My tragedy is much greater because I am a free thinker.
Theoretically, I consider a “goi” [gentile] just as much a man as a
Jew.... Indeed I ask myself these questions: “What would happen if
my daughter married a Jewish fellow who was a good-for-nothing?...
And what do I care if he is an Italian? But I can not seem to answer
these delicate questions. The fact is that I would prefer a refined
man; but I would sooner have a common Jew than an educated _goi_.
Why this is so, I do not know, but that is how it is, of that there
is no doubt. And this shows what a terrible chasm exists between
theory and practice!...”[33]
The tendency of communities and families to regulate so minutely the
behavior of all their members was justified by the fact that in case of
poverty, sickness, death, desertion, or ruin the community or family
assumed the burden, “submitted to the yoke”, as they expressed it. In
case No. 31 the former members of a community still support an abandoned
child though they are in America and the child in Europe.
31. In the year 1912 in a little [Russian] village a father
abandoned his family, a wife and three children. Of the children two
were girls and the third was a boy six months old. The mother
worried along with the children and finally in despair she changed
her religion and married a Christian from a neighboring village. The
children she simply abandoned.
Of course the community of the village where this happened took care
of the three abandoned children. They gave them out to families to
be reared, and the village paid for them by the month. My mother was
by no means a rich woman and felt the need of money, so she took the
boy, for which the community paid.
For some years everything went well, until the great World War broke
out. The village in question was impoverished by the war and was
plundered by various bands of pogromists. Great numbers of Jews were
killed and the community was destroyed.
My mother no longer received the monthly payment for the child;
there was no one to make the payment. But my mother did not have the
heart to throw the poor child into the street. They had become
attached to each other, the child to my mother whom he called
“mamma” and my mother to the child. So my mother kept the child
without pay. That is, she and the child hungered and suffered
together. Now, dear editor, I come to the point.
The family of the writer of these lines was scattered. My father
died at home. I and two sisters are now in America. My mother and
the child are still in the old home. Of course we send our mother
money for her support and this means that we support not only our
mother but also the child of strangers. But it has never occurred to
us here in America to reproach our mother because we are compelled
to send money for a strange child.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account