The Vedanta-Sutras with the Commentary by Sankaracarya: Sacred Books of the East, Volume 1
Religion
The Vedanta-Sutras with the Commentary by Sankaracarya: Sacred Books of the East, Volume 1
Vedanta
The preceding considerations suffice, I am inclined to think, to show
that it will by no means be wasted labour to enquire how Ramanuja
interprets the Sutras, and wherein he differs from /S/a@nkara. This in
fact seems clearly to be the first step we have to take, if we wish to
make an attempt at least of advancing beyond the interpretations of
scholiasts to the meaning of the Sutras themselves. A full and
exhaustive comparison of the views of the two commentators would indeed
far exceed the limits of the space which can here he devoted to that
task, and will, moreover, be made with greater ease and advantage when
the complete Sanskrit text of the /S/ri-bhashya has been printed, and
thus made available for general reference. But meanwhile it is possible,
and--as said before--even urged upon a translator of the Sutras to
compare the interpretations, given by the two bhashyakaras, of those
Sutras, which, more than others, touch on the essential points of the
Vedanta system. This will best be done in connexion with a succinct but
full review of the topics discussed in the adhikara/n/as of the
Vedanta-sutras, according to /S/a@nkara; a review which--apart from the
side-glances at Ramanuja's comments--will be useful as a guide through
the Sutras and the /S/a@nkara-bhashya. Before, however, entering on that
task, I think it advisable to insert short sketches of the philosophical
systems of /S/a@nkara as well as of Ramanuja, which may be referred to
when, later on discrepancies between the two commentators will be noted.
In these sketches I shall confine myself to the leading features, and
not enter into any details. Of /S/a@nkara's system we possess as it is
more than one trustworthy exposition; it may suffice to refer to
Deussen's System of the Vedanta, in which the details of the entire
system, as far as they can be learned from the Sutra-bhashya, are
represented fully and faithfully, and to Gough's Philosophy of the
Upanishads which, principally in its second chapter, gives a lucid
sketch of the /S/a@nkara Vedanta, founded on the Sutra-bhashya, the
Upanishad bhashyas, and some later writers belonging to /S/a@nkara's
school. With regard to Ramanuja's philosophy our chief source was,
hitherto, the Ramanuja chapter in the Sarvadar/s/a/n/asa/m/graha; the
short sketch about to be given is founded altogether on the
/S/ri-bhashya itself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account