The war myth in United States historyHamlin, C. H. (Charles Hunter)
History
The war myth in United States history
Hamlin, C. H. (Charles Hunter)
Propaganda, American; United States -- History; War
The War of 1812, in fact, was a complete failure from every angle.
Our troops were defeated. General Winfield Scott declared that the
army officers were "generally sunk in either sloth, ignorance, or
habits of intemperate drinking," "swaggerers, dependents, decayed
gentlemen utterly unfit for any military purpose whatever."
Muzzey in "The United States of America through the Civil War," Vol.
I, page 253, says: "The War of 1812 was a blunder. It was
unnecessary, impolitic, untimely, and rash." It was primarily the
work of Henry Clay. If the United States had been in any condition
to fight, we should have been of great aid to Napoleon who at that
time was being defeated by Great Britain.
In the peace treaty of 1814, which brought the war to a close, the
causes of the war were not mentioned. The War of 1812 was a war of
paradoxes. It was waged ostensibly in defense of maritime commercial
interests, but the merchant states themselves threatened to secede so
as to stop it. The English Orders in Council, the alleged cause of
the war, were repealed five days after war was declared and before
news of its declaration reached England. The most important battle
of the war, the Battle of New Orleans, was fought after the treaty of
peace had been signed. The United States did not get any of the
desired territory; was defeated in nearly every campaign; and the
capitol was burned by the English. The land was not gained and the
rights on the sea were not granted. England never yielded the right
of impressment, which remained a diplomatic controversy as late as
1842.
In order to save its reputation, the Administration published an
"Exposition of the Causes and Character of the War," prepared by A.
J. Dallas, in which it was denied that the administration had ever
tried to acquire Canada. Madison was a great scholar but not a
strong executive, and it was the war hawks led by Clay who forced the
war upon him and the nation.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Adams, Henry--_John Randolph_.
Hocker, L. M.--"Western Land Hunger and the War of 1812; A
Conjecture". _Mississippi Valley Historical Review_, Vol. X, pages
363-395.
Johnson, Allen--_Union and Democracy_. Chapter 11.
Lewis, H. J.--"A Re-analysis of the Causes of the War of 1812."
_American Historical Magazine_. Vol. VI, pages 306-316, 577-584.
Muzzey, D. S.--_The United States of America Through the Civil War_.
Vol. I, chapter 5.
Pratt, J. W.--_The Expansionists of 1812_.
Simons, A. M.--_Social Forces in American History_. Chapter 13.
CHAPTER IV
THE WAR WITH MEXICO
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account