How astonished Pericles and his circle of architects and sculptors would
be could they stand on the corner of Broadway and Twenty-eighth Street
and see the miniature Parthenon that graces the roof of a pile innocent
of other Greek ornament? They would also recognize their old friends,
the ladies of the Erechtheum, doing duty on the Reveillon Building across
the way, pretending to hold up a cornice, which, being in proportion to
the building, is several hundred times too big for them to carry. They
can’t be seen from the sidewalk,—the street is too narrow for that,—but
such trifles don’t deter builders from decorating when the fit is on
them. Perhaps this one got his caryatides at a bargain, and had to work
them in somewhere; so it is not fair to be hard on him.
If ever we take to ballooning, all these elaborate tops may add
materially to our pleasure. At the present moment the birds, and angels,
it is to be hoped, appreciate the effort. I, perhaps, of all the
inhabitants of the city, have seen those ladies face to face, when I have
gone on a semi-monthly visit to my roof to look for leaks!
“It’s all very well to carp and cavil,” many readers will say, “but
‘Idler’ forgets that our modern architects have had to contend with
difficulties that the designers of other ages never faced, demands for
space and light forcing the nineteenth-century builders to produce
structures which they know are neither graceful nor in proportion!”
If my readers will give themselves the trouble to glance at several
office buildings in the city, they will realize that the problem is not
without a solution. In almost every case where the architect has
refrained from useless decoration and stuck to simple lines, the result,
if not beautiful, has at least been inoffensive. It is where
inappropriate elaboration is added that taste is offended. Such
structures as the Singer building, corner of Liberty Street and Broadway,
and the home of _Life_, in Thirty-first Street, prove that beauty and
grace of façade can be adapted to modern business wants.
Feeling as many New Yorkers do about this defacing of what might have
been the most beautiful of modern cities, it is galling to be called upon
to admire where it is already an effort to tolerate.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account