The White Eagle of PolandBenson, E. F. (Edward Frederic)
History
The White Eagle of Poland
Benson, E. F. (Edward Frederic)
Poland -- History -- German occupation, 1914-1918; Polish question
However, the will of the people, self-determination, may constitute,
even if ethnographically the conclusion is unsound, a reason for the
fusion of one nationality in another, and our author asserts that a
Lithuanian plebiscite would vote for inclusion in this new state. But
even allowing that reports from Lithuania are coloured in Germany (which
in itself does not seem probable, since Germany has before now
considered the possibility of uniting the Kingdoms of Poland and
Lithuania under German suzerainty, and so would not emphasize the
dissonance between Poles and Lithuanians), such evidence as is
accessible does not bear out this assertion. For the inhabitants of
Lithuania have repeatedly protested against a fusion with Poland,
regarding the Poles as their bitterest enemies. In 1916, for instance,
the Lithuanian Socialists demanded independence, and declared against
union with Poland: the Union of White Russian peasants in the following
year (at a Congress they held at Minsk) issued a proclamation demanding
union with Russia; in 1917 the Lithuanian Army Congress in Petrograd
demanded that Lithuanians then included in Polish regiments should be
allowed to transfer themselves to Russian regiments. Such instances, it
is submitted, are tangible evidence against a mere assertion, in support
of which no evidence is produced.
It is, moreover, a dangerous thing to lay too much stress on the value
of the bond of religion in such a consolidation as this unless that bond
is cemented by the stronger ties of blood, for while religious
differences have often constituted a cause of quarrel, we do not, as a
matter of practical experience, find that a unity in religion
constitutes a very binding force, except when, perhaps, there is
religious persecution which brings co-religionists together. Such has
not been the case in Lithuania, and as a matter of fact Polish and
Lithuanian co-religionists have before now arrived at a very acute pass
in the matter of the language to be used in churches, Lithuanians
advocating a Lithuanian ritual, in those portions of the mass where
Latin is not used, and Poles championing their own tongue. In fact, the
religious bond has been the cause of considerable differences in
opinion, and free fights have taken place in churches. Accounts of such
disturbances have no doubt been exaggerated, but it is important to
avoid exaggeration on the other side, and find in a common religion a
valid cause for incorporating Lithuania in the new state. This religious
bond, moreover, whatever it is worth, is only applicable as between
racial Lithuanians and Poles. But in the three provinces which
constitute Lithuania the numerical majority of the inhabitants are White
Russian, whose national religion is not Roman Catholic but Greek
orthodox. If then a common religion binds two of these nationalities,
the same bond is equally valid between Russians and White Russians.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account