The Winning of Popular Government: A Chronicle of the Union of 1841MacMechan, Archibald
History
The Winning of Popular Government: A Chronicle of the Union of 1841
MacMechan, Archibald
Canada -- History -- 1841-1867
In the eyes of Durham's enemies his ordinance of banishment was a
ukase; and, at first blush, it looks like an unwarrantable stretching
of his powers. But Durham was on the ground and must necessarily have
known the conditions prevailing much better than his critics three
thousand miles away. Desperate diseases need desperate remedies. The
presumption is always that the man on the ground will be right; and
posterity has {19} passed a final judgment of approval on Durham's bold
slashing of the Gordian knot. New facts have set the whole matter in a
new light. A paper of Buller's,[2] hitherto unpublished, shows that
the ordinance was promulgated _only after consultation with the
prisoners_. 'The prisoners who expected the government to avail itself
of its power of packing a jury were very ready to petition to be
disposed of without trial, and as I had in the meantime ascertained
that the proposed mode of dealing with them would not be condemned by
the leading men of the British party, Lord Durham adopted the plan
proposed.' They regarded banishment as an unexpected mercy, as well
they might. The only alternative was the dock, the condemned cell, and
the gallows.
On the thirtieth of November Durham landed at Plymouth, and by the
middle of the following January he had finished his Report. Early in
February it was printed and laid before the House of Commons. The {20}
curious legend which credits Buller with the authorship is traceable to
Brougham's spite. Macaulay and Brougham met in a London street. The
great Whig historian praised the Report. Brougham belittled it. 'The
matter,' he averred, 'came from a felon, the style from a coxcomb, and
the Dictator furnished only six letters, D-u-r-h-a-m.' The whole
question has been carefully discussed by Stuart J. Reid in his _Life
and Letters of the First Earl of Durham_, and the myth has been given
its quietus. Even if direct external evidence were lacking, a
dispassionate examination of the document itself would dispose of the
legend. In style, temper, and method it is in the closest agreement
with Durham's public dispatches and private letters.
The drafting of this most notable of state papers was the last of
Durham's services to the Empire. A little more than a year later he
was dead and laid to rest in his own county. Fifty thousand people
attended his funeral. A mausoleum in the form of a Greek temple marks
his grave. The funds for this monument were raised by public
subscription, such was the force of popular esteem. His dying words
were prophetic: 'Canada will one day do justice to my memory.'
{21}
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account