He had a case where two men had got into a fight. It was proven that Lincoln's man had merely defended himself against the other's attack. But the other attorney insisted that Lincoln's man could have defended himself less violently. Lincoln closed out the argument and won his case with a story. "That reminds me," said Lincoln, "of the man who was attacked by a farmer's dog. He defended himself so violently with a pitchfork that he killed the dog. "'What made you kill my dog?' demanded the angry farmer. "'Because he tried to bite me,' replied the victim. "'Well, why didn't you go at him with the other end of the pitchfork?' persisted the farmer. "'Well, I would,' replied the man, 'if he had come at me with the other end of the dog.'" IV. TURBULENT TIMES AND SOCIAL STORMS One of the most singular, as well as undignified, experiences of Lincoln is closely involved in the most important measures of his life. This refers to the duel which he never fought with a man who was a stormy disturber for many years in many exalted yet unbecoming affairs. In 1840 Lincoln became engaged to Miss Mary Todd of Lexington, Kentucky, who was visiting her sister, Mrs. Ninian Edwards of Springfield. She came of a noted and rather aristocratic family of Kentucky. That two persons, so unlike in ancestry, in social experience, and in education, should be attracted to each other has seemed to be mystery enough to breed much speculation, a great number of curious stories, and much ungracious comment. Lincoln was aware of these differences as much as any one, and this, if there were no other cause, would account for his seeming uncertainties, his hesitation and the delays in his courting affairs which have been the source of so much elaboration and explanation. Lincoln had much social self-depreciation and he had a poetical fancy idealizing his own sensitiveness toward women. It may well be concluded that his judgment was helplessly unsettled from the impossibility of any foresight in a matter of such vital life-importance. The endless gossip that swarmed about Lincoln's love affairs may well be dismissed as worthless in the presence of the facts. Lincoln married Mary Todd November 4, 1842. During the summer before, in commercial and political affairs, there had arisen the greatest dissatisfaction with the money-interests and currency of the state. The current money had depreciated to half its value. Though the people had to use that kind of money in all their transactions, the state officers required their salaries to be paid in gold. The auditor of the State was a young Irishman named James Shields. He was exceedingly vain, pompous and of violent temper. Therefore, he was a shining mark for the wit of those opposed to the present management of the state. In the "Sangamo Journal" there appeared an article of witty satire, ridiculing Shields and the financial methods of his political associates. It was signed, "Rebecca from Lost Townships."