The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21Berkeley, George
Philosophy
The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21
Berkeley, George
Philosophy -- Early works to 1800
88. Having finished what I intended to say concerning the Distance and
Magnitude of objects, I come now to treat of the manner wherein the mind
perceives by sight their Situation(379). Among the discoveries of the last
age, it is reputed none of the least, that the manner of vision has been
more clearly explained than ever it had been before. There is, at this
day, no one ignorant that the pictures of external objects are painted on
the retina or fund of the eye; that we can see nothing which is not so
painted; and that, according as the picture is more distinct or confused,
so also is the perception we have of the object(380). But then, in this
explication of vision, there occurs one mighty difficulty, viz. the
objects are painted in an inverted order on the bottom of the eye: the
upper part of any object being painted on the lower part of the eye, and
the lower part of the object on the upper part of the eye; and so also as
to right and left. Since therefore the pictures are thus inverted, it is
demanded, how it comes to pass that we see the objects erect and in their
natural posture?
[Illustration]
Figure 4
89. In answer to this difficulty, we are told that the mind, perceiving an
impulse of a ray of light on the upper part of the eye, considers this ray
as coming in a direct line from the lower part of the object; and, in like
manner, tracing the ray that strikes on the lower part of the eye, it is
directed to the upper part of the object. Thus, in the adjacent figure,
_C_, the lower point of the object _ABC_, is projected on _c_ the upper
part of the eye. So likewise, the highest point _A_ is projected on _a_
the lowest part of the eye; which makes the representation _cba_ inverted.
But the mind—considering the stroke that is made on _c_ as coming in the
straight line _Cc_ from the lower end of the object; and the stroke or
impulse on _a_, as coming in the line _Aa_ from the upper end of the
object—is directed to make a right judgment of the situation of the object
_ABC_, notwithstanding the picture of it be inverted. Moreover, this is
illustrated by conceiving a blind man, who, holding in his hands two
sticks that cross each other, doth with them touch the extremities of an
object, placed in a perpendicular situation(381). It is certain this man
will judge that to be the upper part of the object which he touches with
the stick held in the undermost hand, and that to be the lower part of the
object which he touches with the stick in his uppermost hand. This is the
common explication of the erect appearance of objects, which is generally
received and acquiesced in, being (as Mr. Molyneux tells us, _Diopt._ part
ii. ch. vii. p. 289) “allowed by all men as satisfactory.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account