The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21Berkeley, George
Philosophy
The Works of George Berkeley. Vol. 1 of 4: Philosophical Works, 1705-21
Berkeley, George
Philosophy -- Early works to 1800
118. Hitherto of Natural Philosophy. We come now to make some inquiry
concerning that other great branch of speculative knowledge, to wit,
Mathematics(723). These, how celebrated soever they may be for their
clearness and certainty of demonstration, which is hardly anywhere else to
be found, cannot nevertheless be supposed altogether free from mistakes,
if in their principles there lurks some secret error which is common to
the professors of those sciences with the rest of mankind. Mathematicians,
though they deduce their theorems from a great height of evidence, yet
their first principles are limited by the consideration of Quantity. And
they do not ascend into any inquiry concerning those transcendental maxims
which influence all the particular sciences; each part whereof,
Mathematics not excepted, doth consequently participate of the errors
involved in them. That the principles laid down by mathematicians are
true, and their way of deduction from those principles clear and
incontestible, we do not deny. But we hold there may be certain erroneous
maxims of greater extent than the object of Mathematics, and for that
reason not expressly mentioned, though tacitly supposed, throughout the
whole progress of that science; and that the ill effects of those secret
unexamined errors are diffused through all the branches thereof. To be
plain, we suspect the mathematicians are no less deeply concerned than
other men in the errors arising from the doctrine of abstract general
ideas, and the existence of objects without the mind.
119. Arithmetic hath been thought to have for its object abstract ideas of
_number_. Of which to understand the properties and mutual habitudes, is
supposed no mean part of speculative knowledge. The opinion of the pure
and intellectual nature of numbers in abstract has made them in esteem
with those philosophers who seem to have affected an uncommon fineness and
elevation of thought. It hath set a price on the most trifling numerical
speculations, which in practice are of no use, but serve only for
amusement; and hath heretofore so far infected the minds of some, that
they have dreamed of mighty _mysteries_ involved in numbers, and attempted
the explication of natural things by them. But, if we narrowly inquire
into our own thoughts, and consider what has been premised, we may perhaps
entertain a low opinion of those high flights and abstractions, and look
on all inquiries about numbers only as so many _difficiles nugae_, so far
as they are not subservient to practice, and promote the benefit of life.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account