The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 05 (of 12): Dresden Edition—DiscussionsIngersoll, Robert Green
Religion
The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 05 (of 12): Dresden Edition—Discussions
Ingersoll, Robert Green
Free thought
_Answer_. Yes, he always was merciful and kind
and patient. Infidels have taken the ground that he
visited them with plagues and disease and famine;
that he had them bitten by serpents, and now and
then allowed the ground to swallow a few thousands
of them, and in other ways saw to it that they were
kept as comfortable and happy as was consistent with
good government; but all these things were for their
good; and the fact is, infidels have no real sense of
justice.
_Question_. How did God happen to treat the Is-
raelites in this way, when he had promised Abraham
that he would take care of his progeny, and when he
had promised the same to the poor wretches while
they were slaves in Egypt?
_Answer_. Because God is unchangeable in his na-
384
ture, and wished to convince them that every being
should be perfectly faithful to his promise.
_Question_. Was God driven to madness by the
conduct of his chosen people?
_Answer_. Almost.
_Question_. Did he know exactly what they would
do when he chose them?
_Answer_. Exactly.
_Question_. Were the Jews guilty of idolatry?
_Answer_. They were. They worshiped other gods
--gods made of wood and stone.
_Question_. Is it not wonderful that they were not
convinced of the power of God, by the many mira-
cles wrought in Egypt and in the wilderness?
_Answer_. Yes, it is very wonderful; but the Jews,
who must have seen bread rained from heaven; who
saw water gush from the rocks and follow them up hill
and down; who noticed that their clothes did not
wear out, and did not even get shiny at the knees,
while the elbows defied the ravages of time, and
their shoes remained perfect for forty years; it is
wonderful that when they saw the ground open
and swallow their comrades; when they saw God
talking face to face with Moses as a man talks with
his friend; after they saw the cloud by day and the
385
pillar of fire by night,--it is absolutely astonishing
that they had more faith in a golden calf that they
made themselves, than in Jehovah.
_Question_. How is it that the Jews had no confi-
dence in these miracles?
_Answer_. Because they were there and saw them.
_Question_. Do you think that it is necessary for
us to believe all the miracles of the Old Testament
in order to be saved?
_Answer_. The Old Testament is the foundation of
the New. If the Old Testament is not inspired, then
the New is of no value. If the Old Testament is
inspired, all the miracles are true, and we cannot
believe that God would allow any errors, or false
statements, to creep into an inspired volume, and to
be perpetuated through all these years.
_Question_. Should we believe the miracles, whether
they are reasonable or not?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account