The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 05 (of 12): Dresden Edition—DiscussionsIngersoll, Robert Green
Religion
The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 05 (of 12): Dresden Edition—Discussions
Ingersoll, Robert Green
Free thought
The idea that God will save a man simply because
he is honest and generous, is almost too preposterous
for serious refutation. No man should rely upon his
own goodness. He should plead the virtue of another.
God, in his infinite justice, damns a good man on his
own merits, and saves a bad man on the merits of
another. The repentant murderer will be an angel
of light, while his honest and unoffending victim will
be a fiend in hell.
A little while ago, a ship, disabled, was blown about
the Atlantic for eighty days. Everything had been
eaten. Nothing remained but bare decks and hunger.
The crew consisted of Captain Kruger and nine others.
For nine days, nothing had been eaten. The captain,
taking a revolver in his hand, said: "Mates, some
"one must die for the rest. I am willing to sacrifice
"myself for you." One of his comrades grasped his
hand, and implored him to wait one more day. The
next morning, a sail was seen upon the horizon, and
the dying men were rescued.
To an ordinary man,--to one guided by the light of
79
reason,--it is perfectly clear that Captain Kruger was
about to do an infinitely generous action. Yet Mr.
Talmage will tell us that if that captain was not a
Christian, and if he had sent the bullet crashing
through his brain in order that his comrades might eat
his body, and live to reach their wives and homes,--
his soul, from that ship, would have gone, by dark
and tortuous ways, down to the prison of eternal pain.
Is it possible that Christ would eternally damn a
man for doing exactly what Christ would have done,
had he been infinitely generous, under the same cir-
cumstances? Is not self-denial in a man as praise-
worthy as in a God? Should a God be worshiped,
and a man be damned, for the same action?
According to Mr. Talmage, every soldier who fought
for our country in the Revolutionary war, who was
not a Christian, is now in hell. Every soldier, not a
Christian, who carried the flag of his country to vic-
tory--either upon the land or sea, in the war of 1812,
is now in hell. Every soldier, not a Christian, who
fought for the preservation of this Union,--to break
the chains of slavery--to free four millions of people
--to keep the whip from the naked back--every man
who did this--every one who died at Andersonville
and Libby, dreaming that his death would help make
80
the lives of others worth living, is now a lost and
wretched soul. These men are now in the prison of
God,--a prison in which the cruelties of Libby and
Andersonville would be regarded as mercies,--in
which famine would be a joy.
THIRD INTERVIEW.
_Sinner. Is God infinite in wisdom and power?
Parson. He is.
Sinner. Does he at all times know just what ought
to be done?
Parson. He does.
Sinner. Does he always do just what ought to be
done?
Parson. He does.
Sinner. Why do you pray to him?
Parson. Because he is unchangeable._
_Question_. I want to ask you a few questions
about Mr. Talmage's third sermon. What do
you think of it?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account