The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 08 (of 12): Dresden Edition—InterviewsIngersoll, Robert Green
Religion
The Works of Robert G. Ingersoll, Vol. 08 (of 12): Dresden Edition—Interviews
Ingersoll, Robert Green
Free thought
_Answer_. A few years ago the Deists denied the inspiration of
the Bible on account of its cruelty. At the same time they worshiped
what they were pleased to call the God of Nature. Now we are
convinced that Nature is as cruel as the Bible; so that, if the
God of Nature did not write the Bible, this God at least has caused
earthquakes and pestilence and famine, and this God has allowed
millions of his children to destroy one another. So that now we
have arrived at the question--not as to whether the Bible is inspired
and not as to whether Jehovah is the real God, but whether there
is a God or not. The intelligence of Christendom to-day does not
believe in an inspired art or an inspired literature. If there be
an infinite God, inspiration in some particular regard would be a
patch--it would be the puttying of a crack, the hiding of a defect
--in other words, it would show that the general plan was defective.
_Question_. Do you consider any religion adequate?
_Answer_. A good man, living in England, drawing a certain salary
for reading certain prayers on stated occasions, for making a few
remarks on the subject of religion, putting on clothes of a certain
cut, wearing a gown with certain frills and flounces starched in
an orthodox manner, and then looking about him at the suffering
and agony of the world, would not feel satisfied that he was doing
anything of value for the human race. In the first place, he would
deplore his own weakness, his own poverty, his inability to help
his fellow-men. He would long every moment for wealth, that he
might feed the hungry and clothe the naked--for knowledge, for
miraculous power, that he might heal the sick and the lame and that
he might give to the deformed the beauty of proportion. He would
begin to wonder how a being of infinite goodness and infinite power
could allow his children to die, to suffer, to be deformed by
necessity, by poverty, to be tempted beyond resistance; how he
could allow the few to live in luxury, and the many in poverty and
want, and the more he wondered the more useless and ironical would
seem to himself his sermons and his prayers. Such a man is driven
to the conclusion that religion accomplishes but little--that it
creates as much want as it alleviates, and that it burdens the
world with parasites. Such a man would be forced to think of the
millions wasted in superstition. In other words, the inadequacy,
the uselessness of religion would be forced upon his mind. He
would ask himself the question: "Is it possible that this is a
divine institution? Is this all that man can do with the assistance
of God? Is this the best?"
_Question_. That is a perfectly reasonable question, is it not,
Colonel Ingersoll?
_Answer_. The moment a man reaches the point where he asks himself
this question he has ceased to be an orthodox Christian. It will
not do to say that in some other world justice will be done. If
God allows injustice to triumph here, why not there?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account