The Works of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke, Vol. 11 (of 12)Burke, Edmund
History
The Works of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke, Vol. 11 (of 12)
Burke, Edmund
Great Britain -- Politics and government -- 1760-1820; Political science -- Early works to 1800
My Lords, I will now assume the hypothesis that he at last discovered
sufficient proof of rebellious practices; still even this gave him no
right to adduce such rebellion in justification of resolutions which he
had taken, of acts which he had done, before he knew anything of its
existence. To such a plea we answer, and your Lordships will every one
of you answer,--"You shall not by a subsequent discovery of rebellious
practices, which you did not know at the time, and which you did not
even believe, as you have expressly told us here, justify your conduct
prior to that discovery." If the conspiracy which he falsely imputes to
Cheyt Sing, if that wild scheme of driving the English out of India, had
existed, think in what miserable circumstances we stand as prosecutors,
and your Lordships as judges, if we admit a discovery to be pleaded in
justification of antecedent acts founded upon the assumed existence of
that which he had no sort of proof, knowledge, or belief of!
My Lords, we shall now proceed to another circumstance, not less
culpable in itself, though less shocking to your feelings, than those to
which I have already called your attention: a circumstance which throws
a strong presumption of guilt upon every part of the prisoner's conduct.
Having formed all these infernal plots in his mind, but uncertain which
of them he should execute, uncertain what sums of money he should
extort, whether he should deliver up the Rajah to his enemy or pillage
his forts, he goes up to Benares; but he first delegates to himself all
the powers of government, both civil and military, in the countries
which he was going to visit.
My Lords, we have asserted in our charge that this delegation and
division of power was illegal. He invested _himself_ with this
authority; for _he_ was the majority in the Council: Mr. Wheler's
consent or dissent signifying nothing. He gave himself powers which the
act of Parliament did not give him. He went up to Benares with an
illegal commission, civil and military; and to prove this I shall beg
leave to read the provisions of the act of Parliament. I shall show what
the creature ought to be, by showing the law of the creator: what the
legislature of Great Britain meant that Governor Hastings should be, not
what he made himself.
[_Mr. Burke then read the seventh section of the act._]
Now we do deny that there is by this act given, or that under this act
there can be given, to the government of India, a power of dividing its
unity into two parts, each of which shall separately be a unity and
possess the power given to the whole. Yet, my Lords, an agreement was
made between him and Mr. Wheler, that he (Mr. Hastings) should have
every power, civil and military, in the upper provinces, and that Mr.
Wheler should enjoy equal authority in the lower ones.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account