The World of Flying Saucers: A Scientific Examination of a Major Myth of the Space AgeMenzel, Donald H. (Donald Howard)
Science
The World of Flying Saucers: A Scientific Examination of a Major Myth of the Space Age
Menzel, Donald H. (Donald Howard)
Unidentified flying objects
Let us begin by reviewing the facts about the visual target. According
to the witnesses on the ground, it was a brilliant bluish-white light
that appeared on the northeast horizon and remained stationary during
most of the period it was observed. At one time it seemed to advance
rapidly toward the witnesses, make a wide sweep around Rapid City,
which was a few miles away from the observers, and then return to
its original position. According to the witnesses in the air, the
light did not remain stationary but retreated from the pursuing plane
and followed the returning plane, duplicating the plane’s speed and
keeping the distance between them constant. The pilots based this
interpretation, evidently, on the fact that the light did not vary in
size or brilliance and thus seemed to pace the plane.
These descriptions all point to the same answer: that the light was a
star or a planet. Since it was infinitely distant, the jets could not
get any closer to it and at ground levels the image was distorted by
peculiar atmospheric conditions. Mars had been absent from the night
sky for months, and Mercury, Venus, and Jupiter were then morning
stars; therefore the unknown could not have been a planet. However,
the bright star Capella was on the northeast horizon at a declination
of plus 46 degrees and would have been visible from both Fargo and
Rapid City. A check of the Weather Bureau records shows that the night
was clear and dark. The sun had set about an hour before the sighting
began, and at that time in the evening there was no moonlight because
the moon was in its last quarter. Visibility was about thirty-five
miles and the wind was from the northeast, about four meters per
second. There was a marked temperature inversion--9 degrees--at ground
levels. Such an inversion could easily account for the erratic motions
reported for the light.
There can be little doubt that the visual target was the star Capella.
The radar targets also were clearly the result of weather, just as the
air-traffic controller had suspected when he first looked at the scope.
Conditions were ideal--a calm, clear, warm summer night--for phantom
echoes. The first radar target, moving southwest, was probably a return
from some ground object. When the jet took to the air, the scope showed
a different kind of UFO target, one that echoed the movements of the
plane itself--retreating from the pursuer, advancing when the pursuer
turned back--and was always farther away from the ground station than
the plane itself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account