The Zincali: An Account of the Gypsies of SpainBorrow, George
History
The Zincali: An Account of the Gypsies of Spain
Borrow, George
Romanies -- Languages; Romanies -- Spain
many others may be traced to foreign tongues, especially the Latin and
Italian. Perhaps one of the strongest grounds for concluding that the
origin of language was divine is the fact that no instance can be adduced
of the invention, we will not say of a language, but even of a single
word that is in use in society of any kind. Although new dialects are
continually being formed, it is only by a system of modification, by
which roots almost coeval with time itself are continually being
reproduced under a fresh appearance, and under new circumstances. The
third assertion of Hervas, as to the Gitános speaking the allegorical
language of which he exhibits specimens, is entitled to about equal
credence as the two former. The truth is, that the entire store of
erudition of the learned Jesuit, and he doubtless was learned to a
remarkable degree, was derived from books, either printed or manuscript.
He compared the Gypsy words in the publication of Grellmann with various
vocabularies, which had long been in existence, of the robber jargons of
Spain and Italy, which jargons by a strange fatuity had ever been
considered as belonging to the Gypsies. Finding that the Gypsy words of
Grellmann did not at all correspond with the thieves’ slang, he concluded
that the Gypsies of Spain and Italy had forgotten their own language, and
to supply its place had invented the jargons aforesaid, but he never gave
himself the trouble to try whether the Gypsies really understood the
contents of his slang vocabularies; had he done so, he would have found
that the slang was about as unintelligible to the Gypsies as he would
have found the specimens of Grellmann unintelligible to the thieves had
he quoted those specimens to them. The Gypsies of Spain, it will be
sufficient to observe, speak the language of which a vocabulary is given
in the present work, and those of Italy who are generally to be found
existing in a half-savage state in the various ruined castles, relics of
the feudal times, with which Italy abounds, a dialect very similar, and
about as much corrupted. There are, however, to be continually found in
Italy roving bands of Rommany, not natives of the country, who make
excursions from Moldavia and Hungaria to France and Italy, for the
purpose of plunder; and who, if they escape the hand of justice, return
at the expiration of two or three years to their native regions, with the
booty they have amassed by the practice of those thievish arts, perhaps
at one period peculiar to their race, but at present, for the most part,
known and practised by thieves in general. These bands, however, speak
the pure Gypsy language, with all its grammatical peculiarities. It is
evident, however, that amongst neither of these classes had Hervas pushed
his researches, which had he done, it is probable that his investigations
would have resulted in a work of a far different character from the
confused, unsatisfactory, and incorrect details of which is formed his
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account