"Ay, sir," cried the wealthy country gentleman, opposite; "but
their laws, sir, their laws--their wise and equitable courts of
justice--their civil and political liberty, sir--a model for all
nations; and which I hope some day to see fully adopted in this
country."
"May God forbid!" cried Burrel. "As to their political liberty, we
can not speak of it; for a thing that has never existed for ten years
together, without deviating into anarchy on the one hand, or sinking
into tyranny on the other, is something very like a nonentity. As to
civil liberty they have no such thing; and may Heaven avert the day
when an Englishman's house will be open to domiciliary visits at the
caprice of any man or body of men, or when he can not ride twenty
miles without being subjected to interruption, and a demand for his
passport!"
He now found that his conversation was getting too heavy, and would
fain have dropped it; but the other urged him somewhat warmly with,
"Their laws, sir--their laws! their courts of justice!" and Burrel
resolved that he should not rest even upon that.
"As to their courts," he replied, "I have been in many, and never did
I see the forms of justice so completely mocked. The judge renders
himself a party, and that party the accuser. The unhappy man who is to
be tried, placed on an elevated station in the face of all the court,
is himself cross-examined, and tortured by interrogations without end;
every tittle of the evidence against him is urged upon him by the
judge: he is obliged to answer and to plead to the accusation of each
witness on the adverse part, and woe be to him if he trip in the
smallest particular! If ever there was a plan invented for condemning
the innocent and the timid, and letting the guilty and the daring
escape, it is that of a French trial. The only security is in the
individual integrity and discrimination of the judges--in general most
exemplary men."
"That may be all very true, sir," replied the other, who, like many of
our countrymen, had been talked into believing the French system very
fine, without ever taking the trouble of examining accurately what the
French system is--"that may be all very true; but yet their laws,
sir--their laws!"
"I think," replied Burrel, more calmly than he had before spoken; for
the common-place absurdity of the other's commendation of what he did
not understand, had thrown even his cool mind off its guard--"I think,
if you will take the trouble of reading the book which contains their
codes, you will find that it is confined both in scope and detail; and
to show how iniquitous as well as absurd their laws are, we have only
to look at their law of succession, which prevents a man from
disposing of his property at his death, according to his own judgment
and inclination, whether he have acquired it by his personal labor or
by inheritance."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account